Best American Restaurants in Middle Island

Great food ,music ,ambience.the serve Liz was fantastic very attentive and personable went above and beyond to make the Night special!

We are local and visit often. We’re never disappointed!!! Drinks, appys & entries perfect.

We had a wonderful evening… Third year we have had our staff holiday party at Fifth Season … always a great evening.

Food and service were fantastic. Nice surprise given the off the beaten track location in a strip mall. Looking forward to returning.

Another perfect experience. Our waiter, Stamatis, was polished, knowledgeable, charming, helpful, intuitive to our needs, and personable. The entire serving team worked smoothly and seamlessly filling water, bringing bread, clearing empty plates, and performing other necessary tasks. The specials menu was surprisingly reasonably priced and every dish was plentiful, artfully arranged, done perfectly, and absolutely delicious. Again, small things matter. Lemon for our water was brought promptly, appetizers and entrees were brought out at a correct pace, coffee was hot and delicious, leftovers were graciously packed and returned to their corresponding people. Sometimes restaurants excel in only a few dishes. Our orders included stuffed lobster, pork chop, a seafood pasta dish, ribs, as well as a variety of appetizers, and two different desserts that our party shared. Not one of these items was less than stellar. Spending an evening with old friends we hadn’t seen in sometime was exceedingly enhanced by the entire treatment we received at Spiro’s. Anxiously anticipating our next visit.