Best American Restaurants in Fishers Island

77 restaurants available nearby

1. 317 Main Street

4.7

Exceptional(1659)

Price: Moderate

• American • Farmingdale

Booked 28 times today

At 317 Main Street in Farmingdale, the essence of authentic American cuisine is elevated by the culinary wizardry of two-time "Chopped" champion, Chef Eric LeVine. His approach to American Grill dishes with a twist of local flavors sets this restaurant apart. Enthusiastic diners rave about the "scrumptious" meals and the vibrant atmosphere, often highlighted by Chef Eric’s personal table visits, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether it’s the "delicious" brunch options or the expertly mixed craft cocktails, 317 Main Street promises not only a meal but a spectacle of flavors and hospitality that keeps patrons returning. As one diner put it, it's a place that truly makes you "feel at home with great staff, chefs, and food!"

A photo of HARLEYS American Grille restaurant

2. HARLEYS American Grille

4.5

Awesome(1052)

Price: Moderate

• American • Farmingdale

Booked 21 times today

Harleys American Grille, nestled in the heart of downtown Farmingdale, is a beacon for steakhouse aficionados. Known for its prime steaks and vibrant ambiance, Harleys offers an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons rave about the quality of the dishes, with one customer declaring the steak "out of this world" and praising the exceptional service that makes every visit memorable. The restaurant's allure is amplified by its attentive staff and unique cocktails, creating a perfect setting for both casual diners and steak enthusiasts. Whether it's the ribeye eggrolls or the perfectly cooked filet mignon, Harleys ensures a top-tier culinary journey, making it a must-visit destination in Farmingdale.

3. The Halston

4.4

Awesome(240)

Price: Expensive

• American • Melville

Booked 50 times today

The Halston in Melville is a beacon of contemporary American cuisine, offering an eclectic mix of culinary delights that cater to a variety of tastes. Patrons rave about the diverse menu, from the "succulent Branzino" to the "deliciously crafted sushi," each dish is a testament to the quality and creativity infused in every plate. Reviews consistently highlight the "excellent service" and "lively atmosphere," making it a top choice for any occasion. Whether it's the hand-crafted cocktails or the exquisitely presented entrees, The Halston ensures a dining experience that exceeds expectations. As one reviewer put it, "Food was amazing, staff was amazing, this place is perfect for all occasions." This spot is not just a meal; it's a culinary adventure that truly represents the spirit of American dining.

4. Rustic Root

4.6

Exceptional(429)

Price: Moderate

• American • Woodbury

Booked 38 times today

Rustic Root in Woodbury Village is not just a place for delightful meals; it's a haven for cocktail enthusiasts. Recognized for its "wonderful cocktails" and "fun choosing" from an array of crafty mixes, this spot stands out in the cocktail bar scene. Patrons rave about the "Twilight" cocktail, highlighting it as "totally delicious." The commitment to quality is evident, as several guests noted the cocktails are "always a treat" and praised the "best Smokey Old Fashion." With its vibrant and welcoming atmosphere, Rustic Root proves to be a gem where the craft of cocktail-making is both an art and a celebration.

5. The Bryant

4.6

Exceptional(1558)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Huntington

Booked 96 times today

Discover the sizzle of The Bryant, a standout Steakhouse located next to the Walt Whitman Mall in Huntington. Celebrated for its high-quality steaks, The Bryant ensures each dish is cooked to perfection, offering an authentic steakhouse experience that’s hard to match. A favorite among locals, The Bryant is praised for its "always great" atmosphere and exceptional service. As one diner raved, "My 10-year-old son especially loves your steak!" and another noted, "Steak was cooked to perfection, sides were excellent." Whether for a casual dinner or a special celebration, The Bryant's combination of delicious steaks, vibrant ambiance, and meticulous service makes every meal memorable. Join us for an unmatched dining experience where every bite is a delight!

A photo of OHK Bar & Restaurant restaurant

6. OHK Bar & Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(3359)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Huntington

Booked 29 times today

Experience Europe in America at OHK BAR & RESTAURANT at OHEKA CASTLE, and enjoy award-winning cuisine by Executive Chef Raed Jallad. Please be advised of our on-site policies:OHK does not permit decorations, centerpieces, flowers, balloons, music, lighting, vendors or any outside food including cakes. Your reservation is subject to change or cancellation at any time and for any reason. While you may request a specific table, we cannot guarantee it’s availability. The use of professional photography equipment and wedding attire is strictly prohibited. We reserve the right to refuse amateur or professional photography for any reason. Additionally, if an event is occurring at Oheka Castle, guests will be unable to tour the grounds and the mansion.OHK operates as a restaurant within Oheka Castle. For inquiries regarding catering events or parties, please contact Kelly Melius, Director of Sales, or for private dining at OHK Restaurant, please contact Daniel Forman, Restaurant Manager.

A photo of Palmer's American Grill restaurant

7. Palmer's American Grill

4.5

Awesome(1049)

Price: Expensive

• American • Farmingdale

Booked 10 times today

Palmer's American Grill in Farmingdale stands out as a premier Steakhouse destination, renowned for its "perfectly cooked" meats and prime aged steaks. The restaurant's warm, friendly atmosphere complements an upscale contemporary menu, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors. Diners rave about the "spectacular" quality of dishes like the beef Wellington and the NY Strip, often highlighting the exceptional service and the vibrant ambiance enhanced by live entertainment. The glowing reviews consistently mention the attentive and professional staff, with one patron exclaiming, "The food was the star of the show!" Palmer's dedication to excellence is clear, making every meal a memorable dining experience. Whether it's a family gathering or a romantic date night, Palmer's American Grill is a must-visit for authentic, high-quality Steakhouse cuisine.

8. Milleridge Inn

3.9

Excellent(1966)

Price: Expensive

• American • Jericho

Booked 72 times today

Step back in time and enjoy one of Long Island's oldest treasures.Featuring traditional American cuisine, our Restaurant provides Lunch and Dinner service daily. Sunday features our Grand Brunch Buffet including unlimited lobster, shrimp, Nova Scotia salmon, and traditional brunch specialties.After you've enjoyed your meal at the Historic Milleridge Inn, be sure to take a stroll through our quaint village, which resembles Long Island Beginnings with a bakery, general store, and so much more. Please note: Reservations on OpenTable do not apply to the Cottage or special events.

A photo of Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale restaurant

9. Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale

4.4

Awesome(1436)

Price: Moderate

• American • Farmingdale

Booked 8 times today

Caracara Mexican Grill in Farmingdale offers a truly authentic and upscale Mexican dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more. Known for its "excellent food and service," this gem serves up traditional favorites like Tamales and Enchiladas with a creative twist, such as the Pollo Relleno. Guests rave about the "delicious" table-side guacamole and the "best margaritas" they’ve ever had. With a selection of 70 premium tequilas and a cozy tequila lounge, it's perfect for any occasion. As one reviewer puts it, Caracara is "perfection in every way - service, margaritas, food! GO THERE FOR YOUR NEXT MEXICAN FIESTA." Whether you’re in for Taco Tuesday or a special prix fixe dinner, Caracara promises an unforgettable Mexican feast.

10. Market Bistro

4.8

Exceptional(1697)

Price: Expensive

• American • Jericho

Booked 20 times today

Market Bistro in Jericho, New York, stands out as a gem of authentic American cuisine, delighting patrons with its commitment to quality, market-driven, and seasonally fresh ingredients. The restaurant's vibrant ambiance is matched by its exceptional menu, which features contemporary American dishes prepared with a focus on local produce. Patrons rave about the dining experience, with comments like "Always consistently great meal" and "The food and service are always excellent." The bar scene is equally praised, offering an array of local craft beers and expertly mixed cocktails by the renowned mixologist, Sarah. Market Bistro is not just a meal; it's a culinary journey praised for its "extraordinary food" and "exceptional service," making every visit a memorable American dining experience.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

S
Stephen
Orlando / Central Florida East •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Our servers Kenny and Brianna were excellent. They brought a lot of energy and definitely enhanced the dining experience. They both made recommendations that turned out to be on point. The apps were tremendous, tuna tartare and lobster dumplings. We also had the Halston roll and the Holiday roll which was a special, both were off the charts. Everyone enjoyed their entrees except the bronzing which I was told was dry and an overall swing and a miss. The scampi and ribs were delicious. The PB&J desert was ridiculous.
More info
The HalstonPrice: Expensive• American• Melville
•
4.4
R
RICHARDVIP
New York City •15 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
The hostess Jocelyn was awesome, fun and funny. Our waiter was excellent. Food was great no rush to eat or get out. Drinks were excellent.
More info
HARLEYS American GrillePrice: Moderate• American• Farmingdale
•
4.5
J
Joyce
New York City •7 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Food is out of this world. It took exceptionally long to get our food however. We arrived at 6:30 and did not get our food till almost 8. Noise level was a bit loud but we could still talk at our table. Waitress was friendly and prompt. I particularily appreciated how often our water was filled.
More info
Palmer's American GrillPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Farmingdale
•
4.5
OT
OpenTable Diner
San Francisco Bay Area •2 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 11, 2024
We went at an off hour (2 PM) so got stuck between shifts. We lost our waiter halfway through the service. On the plus side we were able to speak with the chef. All of the food was fresh and inventive and locally sourced when possible (Shinnecock Bay scallops). This is a gastropub so expect elevated food in casual but cozy surroundings.
More info
317 Main StreetPrice: Moderate• Gastro Pub• Farmingdale
•
4.7
J
Janine
New York City •5 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 30, 2024
great experience and good was wonderful. We enjoyed our visit.
More info
Caracara Mexican Grill - FarmingdalePrice: Moderate• Mexican / Southwestern• Farmingdale
•
4.4

Explore OpenTable

Fishers Island

American

Best American Restaurants in Fishers Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

77 restaurants available nearby

1. 317 Main Street

2. HARLEYS American Grille

3. The Halston

4. Rustic Root

5. The Bryant

6. OHK Bar & Restaurant

7. Palmer's American Grill

8. Milleridge Inn

9. Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale

10. Market Bistro

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable