Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Caldwell

16 restaurants available nearby

1. Halcyon Brasserie

4.7

Exceptional(1986)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary american • Montclair

Booked 50 times today

Halcyon Brasserie in Montclair stands out as a beacon of Contemporary French and American cuisine, offering a delightful fusion of flavors that captivate the senses. Known for its "phenomenal mussels and oysters," this fine seafood brasserie takes pride in serving the freshest local catches, ensuring authenticity in every dish. The charred octopus and Icelandic cod are particularly praised, with patrons exclaiming that "the punch of pepper oil for the Icelandic Cod is brilliant." The ambiance is equally inviting, with a tranquil atmosphere suitable for romantic dinners or special occasions. Guests consistently celebrate Halcyon as a "hidden gem," delivering an "overall excellent experience" time and again.

A photo of Frank Anthony's Gourmet Italian restaurant

2. Frank Anthony's Gourmet Italian

4.6

Exceptional(302)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary american • Verona, New Jersey

Booked 14 times today

Nestled in the heart of Verona, New Jersey, Frank Anthony's Gourmet Italian is a haven for those seeking authentic American cuisine with a delightful Italian twist. This beloved eatery is renowned for its "excellent and elevated food," offering a diverse menu that captivates every palate. From hand-cut steaks to homemade pastas, every dish is crafted with the finest ingredients, promising a taste of true American quality. Diners rave about the "amazing service and food," highlighting signature dishes like the calamari and artisan pizza. With its inviting atmosphere and consistently outstanding service, Frank Anthony's is a must-visit for any food enthusiast.

3. DelMonico

4.8

Exceptional(596)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary american • Cedar Grove

Booked 15 times today

DelMonico in Cedar Grove is a standout in American cuisine, offering a delightful blend of traditional and innovative dishes that capture the essence of American dining. Known for its "creative cocktails and apps" and a menu that "never disappoints," DelMonico provides an inviting atmosphere where every meal feels special. The steaks are "prime cuts done right," and their seafood, such as the clams casino, is consistently praised. With a welcoming vibe akin to "dinner at a friend's house," this local gem is perfect for both special occasions and casual dinners, ensuring every visit is a memorable culinary experience.

A photo of Carriage House Restaurant restaurant

4. Carriage House Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(1826)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary american • Millburn

Booked 12 times today

Nestled in the heart of Millburn, the Carriage House Restaurant offers an exquisite taste of authentic American cuisine, perfectly harmonizing with the artistic charm of the nearby Paper Mill Playhouse. The restaurant’s “delicious food” and “exemplary service” create a memorable dining experience, whether you're savoring the delectable lemon sole oreganata or indulging in a sumptuous three-course prix fixe dinner. Diners rave about the cozy yet elegant atmosphere, likening it to a “perfect start” to their theater evenings. With its thoughtfully curated menu, featuring everything from “melt-in-your-mouth” short ribs to fresh, vibrant desserts, Carriage House Restaurant is a true gem for American cuisine enthusiasts.

A photo of McLoone's Boathouse restaurant

5. McLoone's Boathouse

4.4

Awesome(3756)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary american • West Orange

Booked 34 times today

Nestled in the scenic South Mountain Recreation Complex, McLoone's Boathouse in West Orange offers an exceptional seafood dining experience that truly stands out. With its prime location on the reservoir banks, the restaurant not only provides breathtaking views but also serves up "outstanding" seafood dishes that leave patrons raving. Their menu features fresh, flavorful options like the "delicious lobster roll" and the "signature crab cake," both of which have garnered glowing reviews from delighted diners. The combination of "excellent service" and "beautiful ambiance" makes McLoone's Boathouse a must-visit destination for seafood aficionados seeking a memorable meal.

6. Matisse 167

4.8

Exceptional(1288)

Price: Very Expensive

• Contemporary american • Rutherford

Booked 12 times today

Matisse 167 in Rutherford is a true gem of American cuisine, offering a dining experience that masterfully combines creativity and tradition. Under the talented helm of Chef Greg Power, the restaurant delivers an exceptional four-course Prix-Fixe Menu that has diners raving. As one guest put it, "Every bite was like winning the flavor lottery." The ambiance is as enchanting as the food, with a charming garden patio and beautifully adorned dining rooms. Known for its BYOB policy, Matisse 167 is perfect for celebrating special occasions. With rave reviews highlighting its "outstanding food and service," it's an American dining experience not to be missed!

7. F1RST

4.9

Exceptional(321)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary american • Hawthorne

Booked 8 times today

F1RST, nestled in Hawthorne, New Jersey, is a shining beacon of American cuisine, blending authenticity with innovative twists. With award-winning Executive Chef Adam Weiss at the helm, this fine dining BYOB restaurant offers a seasonal menu bursting with vibrant flavors and textures. Diners rave about the "masterfully prepared" dishes, highlighting unique creations like the tuna tartare and shrimp and grits. The ambiance is described as both "elegant" and "cozy," enhanced by sophisticated decor and an intimate fireplace. Guests consistently praise the "impeccable" service and the memorable dining experience that F1RST delivers, making it a must-visit destination for American food enthusiasts.

A photo of Nico Kitchen & Bar - Newark restaurant

8. Nico Kitchen & Bar - Newark

4.3

Awesome(1878)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary american • Newark

Booked 14 times today

Nico Kitchen & Bar in Newark is a treasure trove of authentic American cuisine, perfect for unwinding after a long day or enjoying a pre-show meal. Renowned for having "the best fries you'll ever have," Nico's menu offers a delightful array of dishes that consistently earn rave reviews for both taste and presentation. Diners frequently praise the "exceptional" food and "attentive" service, making it a favorite spot for both locals and visitors. The relaxing ambiance, coupled with delicious American classics and a friendly staff, ensures a dining experience that is nothing short of "wonderful" and "memorable."

A photo of The Station at Mountain Lakes restaurant

9. The Station at Mountain Lakes

4.9

Exceptional(1045)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary american • Mountain Lakes

Booked 13 times today

The Station at Mountain Lakes is a delightful gem for anyone craving authentic Creole, Cajun, and Southern cuisine. Nestled in a beautifully restored field stone train station, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience that is both charming and memorable. Executive Chef Bradley Cooper crafts every dish with passion, ensuring each bite is a tribute to the rich culinary traditions of the South. Guests rave about the "creative delicious food" and the "superb service," making it a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're enjoying a perfectly cooked jambalaya or a sumptuous stuffed salmon, The Station guarantees an exceptional Southern dining experience.

A photo of MADISON WINE & TAP restaurant

10. MADISON WINE & TAP

4.6

Exceptional(154)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary american • Madison

Booked 17 times today

Madison Wine & Tap in Madison is a true gem for American cuisine enthusiasts. This vibrant spot boasts a delightful menu crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, offering a taste of authentic American flavors. Reviewers rave about the “fabulous local spot” that consistently delivers “great food and outstanding service.” The restaurant’s lively atmosphere, complemented by live music and an array of TVs for game day, ensures an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re enjoying their world-class pizza or savoring the chef’s special crab cake, Madison Wine & Tap promises a culinary journey that’s “worth the cost” and keeps patrons coming back for more.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

D
Donna
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
I met today at Halcyon for brunch with a friend. The service was fairly attentive. It is a physically appealing venue with a very nice brunch menu. We both ordered the day's special omelette with smoked salmon. The dish was beautifully prepared, though the salmon was overly salty. The guavallini cocktail was delicious. The coffee was, unfortunately, not hot. Overall, it was a pleasant brunch experience and I would come back again.
More info
Halcyon BrasseriePrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• Montclair
•
4.7
C
Carlos
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Blue at the Hudson was an amazing experience, all thanks to Victoria, whose kindness and attentiveness made the experience a 20/10. Victoria is warm, joyful, and graceful. The food was delicious and cooked to perfection. Definitely, must try the meats and cocktails. We had had an amazing experience!
More info
Blu on the HudsonPrice: Very Expensive• Contemporary American• Weehawken
•
4.7
V
vinny
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Great vibes, great food. Overall an excellent experience!
More info
Drift Restaurant & BarPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Weehawken
•
4.6
J
JenniferVIP
New York City •4 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
This is our go-to pre-theater spot. The food is always good, there's something for everyone (even out-of-town guests), the service is always superb, and we always get our check in time to make the show. I'm partial to their Caesar's salad and burger, and the hot fudge pudding dessert, but all the guests I've brought here have also enjoyed their meals (salmon, pasta, you name it).
More info
Joe AllenPrice: Expensive• American• Theater District
•
4.8
C
Cathy
New York City •18 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jan 3, 2025
As always, good and service was great! Also, the room was festively decorated, a great place to celebrate the season!
More info
DelMonicoPrice: Moderate• Steakhouse• Cedar Grove
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Caldwell

Contemporary american

Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Caldwell

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

16 restaurants available nearby

1. Halcyon Brasserie

2. Frank Anthony's Gourmet Italian

3. DelMonico

4. Carriage House Restaurant

5. McLoone's Boathouse

6. Matisse 167

7. F1RST

8. Nico Kitchen & Bar - Newark

9. The Station at Mountain Lakes

10. MADISON WINE & TAP

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable