Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Sanibel

The most delicious food and cocktails. Loved the menu. Lyric our server was outstanding! We are going again tonight.

Our reservation was for 7:15 on Valentine’s Day. P Our waiter was attentive. Drinks came out quickly. Experiences with other restaurants on a holiday has not been favorable—waiting 30-45 minutes past reservation before seating. But we were pleasantly surprised when we walked in. Very few diners waiting for their tables and we only waited about 5 minutes before being seated. Everything seemed to be running like clockwork. Our only disappointment was the scallop dinner was barely room temperature. We did not say anything as it was ok to eat at that temperature but would have preferred them to be a bit warmer. And we knew how busy the kitchen would be. Thank you for running a well-oiled machine!!

Fathoms is one of our favorite restaurants in Cape Coral

Jalene was an amazing server — efficient, polite, and charming. Our meals were hot and delicious. Thank you for a delightful evening.

Met a friend for dinner. We had a wonderful dinner in the screened patio area! Nicole was our server and she was just delightful! So knowledgeable and personable! The chefs amuse at the start-tomato soup-was delicious! We each had a wonderful salad-the wedge and the Caesar. So fresh and a great portion! The scallops were delicious… but the corvina was out of this world! Nice portion served at a perfectly hot temperature and beautiful crisp finish! Some of the best I’ve had in Naples! Served on a bed of delicious carrots! Hot cappuccino was a perfect end to the meal! Bravo!