Best Contemporary Mexican Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

15 restaurants available nearby

1. Camino Riviera

4.8

Exceptional(33)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Little Italy

Booked 20 times today

At Camino Riviera in Little Italy, San Diego, diners are transported on a full sensory journey through the flavors of Yucatán, perfectly blending traditional Latin American essence with a modern twist. The culinary expertise of SDCM Corporate Executive Chef, Brian Redzikowski, shines through an eclectic menu that is both avant-garde and authentically Mexican. Celebrated for its unique atmosphere, Camino Riviera is not just a dining experience but a vibrant social hub. Reviewers rave about the "amazing food" and "exceptional drinks," with cocktails like "Tupac's Revenge" being a crowd favorite. The ambiance is described as "sultry," perfect for an unforgettable evening, with a bar program that honors Latin America's rich spirit heritage, featuring rare mezcal and tequila. Whether it's for the gourmet cuisine, the crafted drinks, or the dance floor vibes, Camino Riviera stands out as a top destination for Latin American culinary excellence in San Diego.

A photo of Puesto at the Headquarters restaurant

2. Puesto at the Headquarters

4.6

Exceptional(3506)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Downtown

Booked 70 times today

At Puesto at the Headquarters in Downtown San Diego, the essence of authentic Mexican cuisine is exquisitely captured through an innovative culinary approach. This family-operated gem is renowned for its "Mexico City-style crispy melted cheese tacos" and handmade non-GMO, organic, maíz azul stone-ground tortillas. Patrons rave about the "fantastic food" with standout items like the shrimp taco and the "divine" Horchata. The ambiance is equally praised, described as "perfect for big group celebrations," making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists. Puesto has not only captured the hearts of its guests but also garnered attention from prestigious media outlets, including National Geographic and the LA Times, ensuring a dining experience that’s both authentic and memorable.

3. El Agave

4.7

Exceptional(2478)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Old Town

Booked 45 times today

El Agave in Old Town, San Diego, is a beacon of Contemporary Mexican cuisine, delighting patrons with its authentic and upscale offerings since 1996. Celebrated for housing the largest tequila museum in the U.S., this restaurant offers more than just a meal; it's a cultural experience. Diners rave about the "top tier authentic Mexican food" and the unbeatable atmosphere that makes every visit memorable. Favorite dishes like the ribeye tacos, tequila shrimp, and sopecitos are consistently praised for their excellence. As described by a satisfied guest, "the food, service, and drinks were phenomenal!" El Agave's commitment to quality and authenticity makes it a standout destination for those seeking the best in Mexican cuisine.

A photo of Crudo Ceviche & Oyster Bar restaurant

4. Crudo Ceviche & Oyster Bar

4.5

Awesome(175)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Little Italy

Booked 20 times today

Crudo Ceviche & Oyster Bar in Little Italy, San Diego, stands as a beacon of Contemporary Mexican cuisine with its innovative approach to seafood. Patrons rave about the "best not Italian restaurant in little Italy" where "every piece of fish and seafood is tremendously fresh, tasty, and plenty!" The restaurant’s unique blend of Baja-inspired dishes like the snow crab claws and octopus carpaccio receive glowing accolades for their freshness and beautiful presentation. The ambiance is equally praised, described as "hip, warm" with an "awesome atmosphere." The combination of finely crafted cocktails, attentive service, and an eclectic menu ensures that Crudo Ceviche & Oyster Bar is a must-visit for an authentic and memorable dining experience.

5. Tahona Bar

4.5

Awesome(626)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Old Town

Booked 15 times today

Tahona Bar, nestled in the historic Old Town of San Diego, is a beacon of Latin American culinary excellence, particularly celebrated for its innovative approach to Mexican cuisine and its extensive mezcal offerings. The restaurant transports diners to a modern Mexican hacienda, complete with traditionally crafted décor and a vibrant atmosphere. Guests rave about the authenticity and creativity of the dishes, with one patron exclaiming, "The food here is amazing! All of the tacos are so creative and delicious" and another highlighting the "incredible flavors" that make Tahona a must-visit. The mezcal cocktails, described as "unique, complex, and delicious," along with their award-winning mixologists, ensure that every visit is both memorable and delightful. Tahona Bar stands out not just for its food but for an all-encompassing Latin American dining experience that is both intimate and exhilarating.

A photo of Puesto Mission Valley restaurant

6. Puesto Mission Valley

4.6

Exceptional(1995)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Mission Valley

Booked 81 times today

Puesto Mission Valley in San Diego epitomizes the essence of authentic, innovative Mexican cuisine, delighting diners with its fresh, non-GMO organic ingredients and heirloom Masienda blue corn tortillas. Celebrated for its "Mexico City-inspired tacos," each dish is a burst of flavor and tradition, with "the filet mignon tacos" often hailed as a must-try. The restaurant prides itself on its vibrant ambiance and exceptional service, making every dining experience memorable. Guests rave about the "amazing food and service," noting that the coconut margarita and pozole taco are standout choices. Puesto consistently exceeds expectations, offering a culinary journey that is both genuine and extraordinary, right in the heart of Mission Valley.

A photo of Old Town Tequila Factory Restaurant & Cantina restaurant

7. Old Town Tequila Factory Restaurant & Cantina

3.8

Excellent(1145)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Old Town

Booked 23 times today

Nestled in the historic heart of Old Town, San Diego, Old Town Tequila Factory Restaurant & Cantina offers a spectacular blend of contemporary Mexican cuisine and panoramic views. Praised for its "stellar taco bar" and "delicious authentic Mexican food," this charming rooftop venue serves dishes crafted from "old world recipes" that promise authenticity and flavor. Guests rave about the "fantastic food and drinks" and highlight the ambiance, with one noting the experience as "like the ultimate beach vacation." Whether it's enjoying a Sunday Champagne brunch or a sunset dinner, the Old Town Tequila Factory provides a vibrant setting perfect for any gathering, complemented by attentive service and "the best happy hour deals." This spot is a must-visit for those seeking a genuine taste of contemporary Mexican cuisine in a picturesque setting.

A photo of Miguel's Cocina - Old Town restaurant

8. Miguel's Cocina - Old Town

4.5

Awesome(30)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Old Town

Booked 32 times today

Miguel's Cocina in Old Town, San Diego, is a treasure trove of Contemporary Mexican cuisine, offering an exceptional dining experience that blends tradition with a modern twist. Patrons rave about the "best Mexican style meal I have ever had," highlighting dishes like the trio burrito combo and the creamy jalapeno white sauce that have become crowd favorites. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in its handmade tortillas and mouthwatering salsas, which are often mentioned in glowing reviews. Guests particularly enjoy the "spicy hot salsa" and "passion fruit margarita," which exemplify the restaurant's flair for combining authentic Mexican flavors with California-inspired creativity. Whether it's the friendly service or the vibrant atmosphere of Old Town, Miguel's Cocina consistently delivers an unforgettable dining experience that keeps diners coming back for more.

9. Fisher's

4.3

Awesome(136)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Little Italy

Nestled in San Diego's vibrant Little Italy, Fisher's stands out for its exceptional Contemporary Mexican cuisine, masterfully blending traditional flavors with innovative seafood creations. Since its humble beginnings in 1989, Fisher's has captivated diners with dishes that are both "authentic from Mexico City and great spice!” as per one ecstatic review. Guests rave about the "unique flavors" and consider the ceviche among the "best ever had." Fisher's not only promises an unforgettable dining experience with its friendly ambiance and "excellent cocktails," but it also delights with attentive service and a menu that makes every visit a culinary discovery. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Fisher's is highly recommended for anyone looking to enjoy top-notch Contemporary Mexican cuisine right in the heart of San Diego.

10. Blind Burro

4.6

Exceptional(672)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Downtown

Booked 6 times today

At The Blind Burro in Downtown San Diego, the spirit and flavors of contemporary Mexican cuisine come alive. Nestled in the vibrant East Village, this restaurant stands out for its fresh, coastal Baja-inspired dishes, which guests adore for their authenticity and creativity. Praised for its exceptional service and lively atmosphere, The Blind Burro offers an array of standout dishes, from sizzling surf & turf tacos to the beloved carne asada chimichangas, described by a patron as "phenomenal." Another diner raved, "The best chips and variety of salsas. Delicious drinks such as the sangria and Margarita on the rocks. Highly recommend the lobster tacos. To die for!" It's clear why this spot is a local favorite, perfect for a pre-game meal or a casual meetup, making every visit a delightful culinary adventure.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

D
Dr . SamVIP
San Diego •30 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Been before and loved it, so we took our brother for his birthday. We ordered multiple appetizers and entrees, sharing all the dishes. Outstanding service (thank you Paolo) and off the charts delicious. The flavors of some the dishes were so brilliant that it's memorable. Try the cheesecake dessert. They make it fresh. Love, love, love.
More info
Crudo Ceviche & Oyster BarPrice: Moderate• Mexican• Little Italy
•
4.5
C
ChristenVIP
San Diego •4 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Cadillac Margarita is a classic yum fest. We enjoyed guacamole, tacos and suiza enchiladas. The foods are a la cart. Our server Danica was patient with the elders in my family and friendly. She made sure we received all of our food and drinks. She is a sharp server. I hope to dine with her again.
More info
Puesto Mission ValleyPrice: Moderate• Mexican• Mission Valley
•
4.6
S
SusanVIP
Atlanta Metro •12 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
So happy to be back & satisfy my craving for their mole! I love the trio so I get to taste all three side-by-side. As always service was amazing! Beto (Alberto) even tried to fix the wobbly table.
More info
El AgavePrice: Moderate• Mexican• Old Town
•
4.7
C
CatherineVIP
London •12 reviews
4.0
Dined 5 days ago
Service at the bar was terrific! The bartender, Ruben, I think was his name, was friendly and made a great mocktail and terrific drinks. We each ordered three different tacos, which were excellent, but they took a little while to arrive… perhaps that’s because we had appetizers at the bar beforehand so I guess we expected the food to arrive a little quickly. Overall, a great experience with Mexican food.
More info
Puesto at the HeadquartersPrice: Expensive• Mexican• Downtown
•
4.6
J
John Paul
San Diego •10 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 16, 2024
Found this restaurant on OpenTable and was not disappointed. The ambiance is incredible and the food matches it perfectly. However, I think the service, at least our server in particular, was extremely helpful and that really made the whole experience that much better for us.
More info
Camino RivieraPrice: Expensive• Contemporary Mexican• Little Italy
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Contemporary mexican

Best Contemporary Mexican Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

15 restaurants available nearby

1. Camino Riviera

2. Puesto at the Headquarters

3. El Agave

4. Crudo Ceviche & Oyster Bar

5. Tahona Bar

6. Puesto Mission Valley

7. Old Town Tequila Factory Restaurant & Cantina

8. Miguel's Cocina - Old Town

9. Fisher's

10. Blind Burro

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable