Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore
Price
- $30 and under
- $31 to $50
- $50 and over
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
18 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- LLindaNew York State •1 review4.0Dined 3 days agoFood was delicious - loved my crispy chicken cutlet! Only issue was missing a way to keep our wine bottle cold at table.More infoITA KitchenPrice: Expensive• Italian• Bay Shore•4.4
- EEVIPNew York City •15 reviews5.0Dined 7 days agoMy friends and I had an exceptional dining experience here, and we were thrilled with every aspect of our meal. The decor and ambiance struck the perfect balance between romantic and classy, creating an inviting atmosphere. We were particularly impressed with the extensive wine list and chose a Napa Valley Cabernet, which was perfect. The food exceeded our expectations, showcasing thoughtful ingredients and masterful preparation. The tomahawk steak, with its beautifully charred exterior and tender, flavorful marbling, was a true standout. We couldn’t resist trying a pasta dish and were delighted by the rigatoni with sausage—perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor. For sides, we shared the creamed spinach and mac and cheese, both of which were incredibly well-executed and far from ordinary. To top it all off, the sugar brownie was the perfect sweet ending to a fantastic meal. Whether you’re planning a night out with friends or looking for the perfect spot for a date, I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant. It’s a night to remember!More infoPrimi Italian SteakhousePrice: Very Expensive• Italian• West Islip•4.8
- JJessicaNew York City •1 review5.0Dined on Jan 6, 2025Wonderful atmosphere and very attentive service. Our waitress was patient with us as we were having a business meeting over dinner and thus took longer than a typical reservation. She was very friendly during touch points while not being overbearing which we truly appreciated and made great recommendations for appetizers.More infoButera's Restaurant of Bay ShorePrice: Moderate• Italian• Bay Shore•4.7
- MMelissaAtlantic City / South Jersey Shore •3 reviews5.0Dined on Jan 4, 2025Beautiful ambiance, amazing food! The owner was very personable. Waiter staff pleasant and polite. All around wonderful experience and will definitely be back. My husband and I loved it. 👍🏼More infoBella ViePrice: Moderate• Italian• Bay Shore•4.7
- VVickiNew York City •31 reviews4.0Dined on Dec 28, 2024Good neighborhood place. It wasn’t busy when we were there, but it still took quite some time for our food to be served. Didn’t enjoy waiting…but I guess that’s the price of freshly-made food. We will continue to eat there.More infoMarys Pizza & RestaurantPrice: Moderate• Italian• East Islip•4.7
Discover best Italian restaurants in Bay Shore
Discover the essence of Italian cuisine in Bay Shore, Suffolk, where a variety of restaurants offer an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of New York State. Each establishment boasts unique interpretations of classic Italian dishes, blending traditional flavors with local ingredients to create mouth-watering menus that cater to all palates. From rustic, cozy atmospheres to modern, elegant settings, the dining scene in Bay Shore provides an ideal backdrop for both casual and sophisticated dining experiences. Patrons can expect top-notch service, high-quality food, and an ambiance that complements the rich, culinary heritage of Italy. Whether you're in the mood for hearty pasta, exquisite seafood, or a fine wine selection, Bay Shore's Italian restaurants promise a memorable dining experience. Embrace the local love for Italian cuisine in this vibrant community, where every meal is served with a touch of Italian hospitality.