Best Italian Restaurants in Bayville

50 restaurants available nearby

1. Gioia

4.6

Exceptional(298)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Oyster Bay

Booked 18 times today

Gioia in Oyster Bay, New York, is a remarkable haven for lovers of Contemporary Italian cuisine, particularly celebrating the flavors of Emilia-Romagna. Revered for its handmade pasta and seasonal vegetable dishes, Gioia creates a dining experience that is both "joyous" and authentically Italian. The restaurant boasts an "authentic feel," with a cozy ambiance and dim lighting that perfectly complement its delicious offerings. Diners rave about the "fantastic service" and innovative menu, featuring standout dishes like the mushroom lasagna and lobster tagliatelle. With glowing reviews highlighting its "sublime culinary experience," Gioia promises a delightful escape into the heart of Italy.

A photo of Stellina Ristorante restaurant

2. Stellina Ristorante

4.7

Exceptional(656)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Oyster Bay

Booked 21 times today

Stellina Ristorante in Oyster Bay is a true gem for lovers of authentic Pizzeria cuisine. Boasting a cozy ambiance that transports diners straight to Italy, this quaint, 40-seater restaurant offers a culinary experience that is both "superb" and "unforgettable." Guests rave about the "amazing" wood-fired oven pizzas, which are crafted with high-quality ingredients and embody the essence of Italy's rich culinary traditions. The pizzas are consistently described as "fantastic" and "delicious," making Stellina a standout in the dining scene. With a passionate staff dedicated to top-notch service, Stellina Ristorante promises a delightful dining journey, leaving diners eager to return.

3. Two25 Restaurant

4.6

Exceptional(63)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Locust Valley

Booked 13 times today

Two25 Restaurant in Locust Valley is an exceptional destination for Pizza Bar cuisine, offering a delightful mix of traditional and contemporary Italian dishes. Their coal oven pizzas are praised as "to die for," showcasing the authentic flavors that keep diners coming back for more. Guests rave about the "fabulous pizza" that perfectly balances crispy crusts with flavorful toppings, making each bite a genuine Italian experience. The ambiance is beautifully set with a welcoming vibe, complementing the outstanding service. Whether you're enjoying a casual meal or a special occasion, Two25's dedication to quality and authenticity makes it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.

4. The Audrey

4.8

Exceptional(29)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • East Norwich

Booked 3 times today

The Audrey, nestled in the heart of Oyster Bay, is a gem of Contemporary Italian cuisine that effortlessly combines sophistication with warmth. Diners rave about the "fantastic food" that feels like "being served in your comfortable living room." This charming spot has earned its place as a local favorite for its "excellent small plates" and "delicious cocktails." The menu elevates comfort foods with an Italian twist, and the ambiance is vibrant and inviting. With a curated wine list and live music, The Audrey offers an unforgettable dining experience. It's the perfect destination for a cozy date night or a lively gathering with friends.

A photo of Hunter The Restaurant restaurant

5. Hunter The Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(625)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • East Norwich

Booked 24 times today

Hunter The Restaurant in East Norwich is a beacon of authentic Mediterranean cuisine with a delightful fusion of French and Spanish influences. Diners rave about the restaurant's "amazing service and food," where every dish is a "dream," from the delectable Duck a L'Orange to the perfectly cooked seafood. The chef-driven menu is a testament to the restaurant's dedication to using only the finest ingredients, turning each meal into a gourmet experience. Guests appreciate the "beautiful service" and "delicious meals" in an elegant setting, making it a "5-star experience" that leaves patrons eager to return for more Mediterranean magic.

A photo of Stellina Cafe and Bakery - Oyster Bay restaurant

6. Stellina Cafe and Bakery - Oyster Bay

4.6

Exceptional(5)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • East Norwich

Booked 1 time today

Nestled in the heart of Oyster Bay, Stellina Cafe & Bakery is a culinary haven that caters to all tastes and cravings, offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

7. La Ginestra - NY

4.9

Exceptional(585)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Glen Cove

Booked 16 times today

La Ginestra in Glen Cove is a true haven for lovers of authentic Sicilian cuisine. With 27 years of tradition, this family-run gem offers a delightful fusion of cherished family recipes and creative specials, ensuring "every morsel is delicious." Known for its "high-end delicious food" and "great atmosphere," diners rave about the exquisite flavors, especially the bronzino and pasta dishes. The welcoming staff, including beloved figures like Gus, Enzo, and Julie, enhance the cozy ambiance, making each visit feel like dining with friends. As one patron perfectly put it, "La Ginestra is our favorite local restaurant," promising an unforgettable Sicilian experience.

A photo of Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria restaurant

8. Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria

4.3

Awesome(3)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Glen Cove

Best of Long Island Italian restaurant, great traditional and new style Italian dishes. Full bar great relaxed atmosphere. Everything from our pizza to hamburgers are made fresh to order. We are family owned and operated and treat our guest as one of the family. lol

A photo of The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar restaurant

9. The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar

4.7

Exceptional(1922)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Huntington

Booked 86 times today

The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar in Huntington stands out as a premier cocktail bar with an "intriguing collection of alluring cocktails" that perfectly complement its exquisite Italian cuisine. Guests rave about the "perfect cocktails and wine pairing," enhancing their dining experience. The ambiance is described as "beautiful and welcoming," making it an ideal setting for a memorable night out. Patrons frequently mention the "superb service" and attention to detail, ensuring every visit feels special. This cocktail bar promises not just a meal but a delightful experience that "never disappoints," inviting diners to return for both its drinks and delectable menu offerings.

A photo of Plado - Glen Cove, NY restaurant

10. Plado - Glen Cove, NY

4.5

Awesome(68)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Glen Cove

Booked 15 times today

Plado in Glen Cove is a Mediterranean gem that brings authentic, high-quality flavors straight to your plate! Chef German Rizzo's expertise shines through in the standout dishes like the taro gnocchi, praised as "light, airy, and with the most delicious truffle sauce." Diners rave about the "superb" small plates that are perfect for sharing, making it an ideal spot for friends and family gatherings. The restaurant's vibrant, warm atmosphere complements its expertly crafted dishes, transforming every meal into a memorable experience. With its fresh ingredients and innovative menu, Plado offers a true taste of Mediterranean cuisine right in the heart of Glen Cove.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

S
SharonVIP
New York City •31 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
The food is extraordinary. It was a lovely dining experience.
More info
GioiaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Oyster Bay
•
4.6
B
Bruce
New York City •12 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
One of my favorite restaurants. From the ambience to the food and the service. I will always come back.
More info
Stellina RistorantePrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Oyster Bay
•
4.7
F
FrankVIP
New York City •226 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Just outstanding and a great dining experience for my family. Although we had two small children with us, our server Miroslav did a terrific job engaging them. The food, as usual, was well prepared and the kitchen did a great job timewise. The tuna tartare I had was perfect, fresh and simple with avocado. A pan-seared fluke with a seafood risotto was terrific. Pastas were also well made. All-in-all an excellent restaurant choice I recommend highly.
More info
Two25 RestaurantPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Locust Valley
•
4.6
A
Alexa
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Kate, one of the waitresses, is the best! Always smiling and in an upbeat, welcoming mood. The drinks are great and service is quick. I really like recommend this place!!
More info
The AudreyPrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• East Norwich
•
4.8
M
MelanieVIP
New York City •10 reviews
5.0
Dined on Jan 17, 2025
Absolutely delicious!! We walked in and the staff was wonderful! The appetizers steamed clams and the grilled octopus was delicious! I got the pork chop special which was perfectly cooked! My husband got the veal chop parmigiana, not only was it huge but absolutely delicious
More info
Hunter The RestaurantPrice: Very Expensive• French• East Norwich
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Bayville

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Bayville

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

50 restaurants available nearby

1. Gioia

2. Stellina Ristorante

3. Two25 Restaurant

4. The Audrey

5. Hunter The Restaurant

6. Stellina Cafe and Bakery - Oyster Bay

7. La Ginestra - NY

8. Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria

9. The Farm Italy Restaurant + Bar

10. Plado - Glen Cove, NY

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable