Best Italian Restaurants in Long Key

Due to mostly hard surfaces, the main dining area is very loud. Now, the food is another story. The food, both my and my wife’s, was spectacular and so was the service. Good drinks and the pours were not stingy.

As always, we had an excellent meal. Drinks at the bar then dinner outside so we can hear the music across the street. We had the eggplant rollatini and linguine in white clam sauce! Delish!

As always we really enjoyed dinner at Antonia’s. The escargot appetizer was the perfect starter. My wife’s scampi special was done perfectly and my branzino dish was delicious. Ian, our server, was professional, engaging and attentive. One of our favorite dining places in Key West. Cheers.

The food and service were exceptional! Best dining experience of our trip. Highly recommend.

We had the absolute best time at Bel Mare. The food was spectacular, and our server was phenomenal. I had the home-made ravioli which was cooked to perfection. I had a chocolate martini which is not an easy drink to make but the bartender was spot on. It was one of the best one I ever had. Even though this was our first time at this restaurant, we felt like we were old friends. We were not rushed and were given such great recommendations on food by our waiter. He was simply the best!! The restaurant is beautiful with amazing views of the marina. I highly recommend this restaurant and cannot wait to return. Thank you for truly an amazing evening.