Best Mediterranean Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

My wife and I had dinner here. The food was excellent as well as the service.

Extraordinary, perfect attitude and attention for all personal are very kind and professional

The drinks were absolutely delicious, and they didn't skimp on the alcohol. I had the salmon with a side of red potatoes. While the salmon was SLIGHTLY fishy, it wasn't distracting. The potatoes were the highlight of the meal, believe it or not. My girlfriend the paella (it had a different name but I don't remember what it was). Lots of delicious seafood in there, and the portion was enough to share. Our servers were an absolute delight. They chit chatted with us, never made us feel rushed, and felt like friends by the time we left. HIGHLY recommend.

We sat outside, a little chilly but the heat lamps took care of that. The evening was perfect and the Old Fashioned coctails were superb. I ordered the Octopus appetizer which turned out to be the Best I’ve ever had topped with roasted potatoes & a relish that was Spectacular!! The best in the Country, and I live in Florida ! I ordered the Pork Chop entree because I’ve been eating seafood all week. Great choice, tender and cooked perfectly & delicious ! My wife had the half chicken and was phenomenal ! All was very filling, so we did not have desert but did have another Old Fashioned for a night cap. Perfectly made ! A great place to end our week at The Hotel Del Coronado! Definitely will be back !!

Great food. I never order swordfish at a restaurant because it is never up to par. Prior to our dining experience, I read several reviews that stated the swordfish was one of the best they ever had. With that said, I went out on a limb and ordered it! So glad I did, the best swordfish I ever tasted.. was to die for! All selections were exceptional!