Best Southwest American Restaurants in Islip

Price

$$
$$$
$$$$

Regions

Suffolk

Neighborhoods

BabylonBay ShoreDeer ParkEast IslipHauppaugeIslip

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeout only

Seating Options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Wheelchair access

38 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

The default order for search results reflects a number of factors, including table availability, restaurant location, search criteria, and restaurant reviews and ratings. In addition, payment made by a restaurant to OpenTable is also a factor for the relative ordering of restaurants.

1. The Lakehouse

4.7

Exceptional(3222)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 34 times today

The Lakehouse in Bay Shore, NY, offers an exceptional French American dining experience, blending the sophistication of French culinary techniques with the comforting flavors of American cuisine. Guests rave about the “outstanding” dishes like grilled oysters, halibut, and Berkshire pork chops, which showcase the chef's finesse and creativity. The ambiance is equally praised, with a beautiful waterside setting that includes stunning views of the Great South Bay. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and hospitality is reflected in the “impeccable” service and meticulously plated dishes. Whether for a special occasion or a casual night out, The Lakehouse promises a memorable culinary journey.

A photo of Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille restaurant

2. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

4.7

Exceptional(585)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Islip

Booked 22 times today

Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille in East Islip, NY, is a seafood lover's paradise, renowned for its "Best Lobster Rolls on Long Island." This restaurant truly stands out with its commitment to quality, offering dishes that are not only delicious but authentically rich in flavor. Diners rave about the lobster bisque, noting it is "rich and creamy with plenty of lobster pieces." The seafood paella is another highlight, impressing guests with its abundance of lobster, shrimp, calamari, and more. With a warm, inviting atmosphere and attentive service, Jackson Hall is a must-visit for anyone seeking an exceptional seafood experience.

3. Salt and Barrel

4.7

Exceptional(1719)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 25 times today

An authentic oyster bar with an urban vibe and vintage soul. Serving classic cocktails, craft taps, and coastal fare with a rotating selection of east/west coast oysters daily.

4. Roadtrip

4.5

Awesome(116)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 13 times today

Roadtrip in Bay Shore is a true haven for barbecue enthusiasts, offering an unforgettable dining experience that promises "melt in your mouth juicy and delicious" brisket and perfectly cooked ribs. The on-site smoked BBQ is a standout, drawing diners back for its authentic and flavorful taste. Guests rave about the large portions and exceptional quality, making it a must-try for anyone seeking genuine American BBQ. The restaurant's unique approach of highlighting different states each week adds a creative twist, ensuring a fresh and exciting menu every visit. With great service and a welcoming atmosphere, Roadtrip is a culinary gem in Bay Shore.

5. ITA Kitchen

4.4

Awesome(987)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 18 times today

ITA Kitchen in Bay Shore redefines what it means to enjoy authentic American cuisine, presented with a delightful Italian twist. Diners rave about the "outstanding food and wonderful service," making it a standout destination for those seeking a memorable dining experience. Reviews highlight the restaurant's innovative take on traditional dishes, such as the "phenomenal table-side mozzarella" and "amazing chicken picante," reflecting a creative fusion that respects classic American flavors. The vibrant atmosphere, coupled with enthusiastic and attentive staff, ensures that every visit is not just a meal but a celebration, making ITA Kitchen a must-visit for American cuisine enthusiasts.

6. Pecado Mexican

4.6

Exceptional(512)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 11 times today

Pecado is highly acclaimed modern Mexican restaurant known for its menu featuring bold flavors and high quality. Offering a sophisticated experience, Pecado will be the perfect place for any occasion. Crafting cocktails use only fresh, seasonal ingredients and offers a vast selection of the finest tequilas and mezcals, as well as a rotating selection of wines from across South America. Whether it’s lunch with a friend, dinner with your family, or a date night hot spot, this is the place to be. With brunch, lunch, and more, there’s something for everyone to enjoy!

7. Captain Bill's

4.8

Exceptional(2074)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 14 times today

Captain Bill's in Bay Shore is a quintessential destination for authentic American cuisine, perfectly blending tradition with innovation. Nestled along the picturesque Great South Bay, diners are treated to not just "delicious meals" but also breathtaking waterfront views. Renowned for its "premium aged steaks and prime rib," this establishment consistently delivers top-notch quality. Regular patrons rave about the "excellent service" and the "outstanding" brunch buffet, which features unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas, and Champagne. With accolades such as being called "one of the best restaurants on the south shore," Captain Bill's offers an inviting atmosphere that makes every dining experience memorable.

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant

8. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

4.8

Exceptional(1030)

$$$$Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 15 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore offers a delightful experience of American cuisine that truly stands out. Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, this charming eatery is celebrated for its "consistently delicious" dishes and "generous portions" that leave diners "extremely happy with their choices." The vibrant ambiance, enhanced by live music on select nights, creates a fun and upbeat dining environment. The attentive staff and personable service add a personal touch, ensuring every guest feels at home. With standout favorites like the Chicken Piccata and Pork Chop, Butera's promises an "11 out of 10" dining experience that never disappoints.

9. View

4.5

Awesome(1931)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • Oakdale

Booked 10 times today

View in Oakdale is a quintessential American dining experience, offering an exquisite blend of land and sea specialties that delight every palate. With its stunning waterfront location, diners are treated to not only "really good food" but also "one of the best" views on the south shore. The menu impresses with authentic American flavors, featuring dishes like "amazing" tuna poke tacos and perfectly cooked branzino. Reviewers consistently praise the "excellent service" and "delicious" offerings, making it a top choice for both locals and visitors. Whether you're enjoying a meal indoors or taking advantage of the outdoor seating, View promises a memorable dining experience.

10. Shandon Court

4.5

Awesome(542)

$$$$Price: Expensive

• Mexican • East Islip

Shandon Court, nestled in the heart of East Islip, is a beacon of authentic American cuisine, consistently celebrated with accolades such as the Long Island Best American/Continental Restaurant. Diners rave about its "high-quality dishes" and "yummy food," with standout favorites like the Strawberry Fields salad and the big soft “everything” pretzel. The restaurant’s commitment to using superior ingredients shines through its well-rounded menu, which pairs beautifully with impeccable service. Guests are treated to a warm, cozy atmosphere with live music that appeals to varied age groups, making Shandon Court a "must-visit hidden gem" for those seeking genuine American culinary delights.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

D
Darrylanne
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Pleasantly surprised to see such lovely decor in a little neighborhood restaurant Greeted by owner and great service from the wonderful weight staff. The food was excellent. The service was great and I would definitely recommend it.
More info
Caracara Mexican Grill - East NorthportPrice: Moderate• Mexican / Southwestern• Northport
•
4.6
C
Cj
2 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Food was as expected - EXCEPTIONAL! Service was AWESOME! This was my first visit to the Huntington location and I enjoyed my dining experience very much for a late lunch. I have visited many times at the Besito location in Roslyn. It is a good choice for quality food and drinks.
More info
Besito Mexican - Huntington NYPrice: Expensive• Mexican / Southwestern• Huntington
•
4.7
M
MichaelVIP
New York City •40 reviews
4.0
Dined 5 days ago
The food was very good with friendly service and a nice atmosphere.
More info
Ruta Oaxaca - PatchoguePrice: Moderate• Mexican• Patchogue
•
4.7
A
ava
New York City •2 reviews
4.0
Dined 5 days ago
One of the best Mexican on Long Island. Great vibe, people, and great food. Always a pleasure
More info
Besito Mexican - RoslynPrice: Expensive• Mexican / Southwestern• Roslyn
•
4.7
J
Joseph
San Francisco Bay Area •4 reviews
5.0
Dined on Apr 5, 2025
Everything was good. Food, service were great. Worth the visit and the money.
More info
Caracara Mexican Grill - FarmingdalePrice: Moderate• Mexican / Southwestern• Farmingdale
•
4.4

Explore OpenTable

Neighborhood
Cuisine Nearby
Mexican Cuisine

Islip

Mexican

Cold Spring Harbor
Bethpage
Chappaqua
Westhampton Beach
Bellerose
Bedford
Amityville
Port Chester
Woodbury
Poughkeepsie
Stone Ridge
Patchogue
Great Neck
St. James
Stony Brook
Rye
South Salem
Rye Brook
Dobbs Ferry
Port Jefferson