Best Oyster Bars in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Always excellent! Service, food, and views are spectacular.

I’m so impressed with the service. Our server was stellar. We came in to celebrate my mom’s birthday for an afternoon reservation. We had two kids and three adults. We did not order an alcoholic drinks or apps it wasn’t the right time for us. Our server was so professional, kind and hospitable despite this. He treated us with an amazing level of respect. We will absolutely be back and will encourage others to come for their service alone.

The Shelter Island Briganyine is our favorite. Excellent service and food. Ample parking and view of the boats. Nice area to take a walk after eating too.

Wow! Happy Valentine’s Day to us! Zack was an amazing server! We asked him to for “dealers choice” and he provided us with the most amazing meals we have had in a long time! He was very personable and fun and had great drink recommenrations, too! The “little stickler” was a great tequila cocktail and made fiancée enjoyed supping Ocho Tequila all night. Thank you for a memorable Valentine’s Day night! 💕🥂🥰

I made a booking for in the Bar area because my boyfriend and I wanted a more casual experience since we are both in the industry and just wanted to relax and enjoy. We put a note in our reservation that we were celebrating our V day early and on arrival to our table were greeted with a wonderful, spacious booth and rose petals that were so unexpected! Our server Eddie was energetic with a perfect balance of casual, Meeting us exactly where we were in our tempo of the evening. Him and his assistant were there exactly when we needed and not anymore We truly had such a better time than we even imagined, we were using a gift card but we will absolutely be back again. Food was wonderful but the service was even better, will be back for both. Thanks so much Eddie for a seamless dinner and the celebration dessert!