Best Seafood Restaurants in Fisher Island

I have been dining at Rusty Pelican for over 20 years and it has only improved with time. They have done some key remodels that brought the place to a more upscale feel inside and out. I usually dine outside and this past experience was wonderful. Service was fantastic, food was exceptional and everyone enjoyed their time. I recommend the Imperial seafood tower, it is excellent for 4 people.

This dining experience was the best of our week in Miami Beach. We are from Philadelphia and booked an inside table because of cool January temperatures. We welcomed the warmth and quietude, but the porch would have been warm enough and the music was lovely and would not have interrupted our conversation had we chosen to eat outside. We shared salads and our family of four ordered a variety of entres including lobster, fish, and chicken. The entres included excellent sauces and nicely paired sides. Among several nice options, the key lime pie was our favorite dessert. The staff was especially kind and genuine.

Ambiance, food and service were stupendous! We had Chilean sea bass, some maki rolls and nigiri, everything excellent, fish very fresh and delicious.

Truly one of the best dining experiences in Miami. The service is personalized, thoughtful, and absolutely above and beyond. Being escorted to the fish counter to choose your fish and preparation was both fun and educational (we learned a lot about a few types of fish we had never heard of!). Prepare to spend at least $100/person, but unlike other similarly priced Miami restaurants-here it’s well worth the expense.

We always make sure to visit here for a breakfast whenever we are in Miami Beach. The food is always excellent. The service is very good and it is a very nice space to relax and enjoy a meal. Always satisfied!