Best Seafood Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price
- $30 and under
- $31 to $50
- $50 and over
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
3 restaurants available nearby
Booked 3 times today
Booked 1 time today
‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- PPamelaVIPNew York City •2 reviews4.0Dined 1 day agoFriendly and attentive staff. Portions a small but leaves room for dessert.More infoFresh SaltPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Old Saybrook•4.6
- KKathleenNew York City •1 review5.0Dined 4 days agoAmazing service and food . Attention to detail and went above and beyond will be going back !More infoThe Restaurant at Baron's CovePrice: Expensive• American• Sag Harbor•4.3
- HhalVIPNew York City •32 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoNever a bad meal, always wonderful service with delicious food…More infoNoah'sPrice: Expensive• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.7
- DDarrenVIPNew York City •23 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoWonderful food, wonderful drinks, wonderful service. It was Valentine’s Day, and there were several tables with a lot of young children. So it was unusually loud for the first half hour or so. That was a bit annoying. Once they left, the vibe definitely improved. Overall, though, I really love this place.More infoThe Palm East HamptonPrice: Very Expensive• Steakhouse• East Hampton•4.6
- JJillVIPNew York City •12 reviews5.0Dined 5 days agoWe had an absolutely fantastic experience at Halyard. From the moment we arrived, the service was warm, friendly, and incredibly attentive, making us feel truly welcomed. The food was just as impressive—each dish was thoughtfully prepared and bursting with flavor. We started with the tuna tartare and the calamari, which came with a delightful surprise—perfectly blistered shishito peppers that added just the right amount of heat. For our main course, the halibut was cooked to perfection, and the Brussels sprouts were crispy and full of flavor. The cheese-laced mashed potatoes were an indulgent, creamy dream. Dessert was an espresso-infused crème brûlée that was both unexpected and absolutely delicious. Halyard exceeded our expectations in every way.More infoThe Halyard Restaurant at Sound ViewPrice: Expensive• American• Greenport•4.5