Best Seafood Restaurants in Penfield

We came in for martinis, oysters, and dinner. The home made jalapeño cheddar sourdough with the honey butter was insanely good. Everything we ordered was incredible!! Thank you for great service, Alanna & Tommy! :) :)

Great selection of Food and Menu Choices...service is always very good. Very comfortable atmosphere too...one of our favorite places to eat in Ontario County...highly recommended!

Hostess and waitress was phenomenal. Waitress Mercedes SP. was very polite curious and helpful with our order. Very attentive with asking if there was anything we needed. Drove an hour to come here and definitely will be back.

Good music, Great service, Excellent food, Awesome atmosphere. A little pricey but well worth it.

To kick off the New Year in style, our party of five had the privilege of dining at The Cove Restaurant at Canandaigua Lake Hotel, and the experience was nothing short of exceptional. For two of our guests, it was their first time dining here, and they left thoroughly impressed. From the moment we arrived, the welcoming staff set the tone for what would be a memorable meal. Service: The service was impeccable--attentive yet unobtrusive. The Food and Beverage Manager, Melina and the gentleman bartender, Ian on duty went above and beyond to accommodate every one of our requests, ensuring that each guest felt valued and cared for. Accommodation: The restaurant's layout was thoughtfully designed, offering a comfortable and inviting setting even amidst the bustling energy of New Year's Day. Despite the busy holiday atmosphere, and overabundant of loud chatter from a rather large engagement party, our group had plenty of space out of the mainstream to enjoy our meal and conversation in a relaxed and slightly serene environment. Food Quality: Although the menu primarily featured only breakfast items due to the occasion, the chef displayed remarkable flexibility by customizing a grilled shrimp on greens salad entrée for one of our senior guests. This thoughtful touch was greatly appreciated, and he thoroughly enjoyed the dish. Every other dish, from the perfectly prepared eggs benedict to various egg, breakfast potatoes and thick smoked bacon dishes were equally outstanding, showcasing fresh, high-quality ingredients and attention to detail. Ambiance: The Cove truly captures the essence of Canandaigua Lake. With stunning views of the lake, warm lighting, and tasteful decor, the ambiance struck the perfect balance between upscale elegance and cozy charm. Decorated nicely and festive for holidays. Final Thoughts: Dining at The Cove was an extraordinary way to start the New Year. The restaurant delivered on all fronts thanks to its professional management.