Best Sicilian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Gorgeous , cozy, comfortable atmosphere. First class cuisine . Impeccable service from beginning to end. Come here for special occasions or just because you’re hungry. You will become part of the family the minute you walk in.

My best friends Birthday so he wanted Italian and chose Butera's. We were not disappointed sever was very nice and the Owner Chef came by to introduce himself and explained his history and menu, you could see the pride in how he spoke and held himself. We started out with the baked clams and they were an instant hit so moist and tender not chewy at all. We both had the Sunday Gravy and it was perfectly cooked. My wife had the chicken meatball pot and they were so tender and melted in your mouth. We are looking forward to going back soon. David H.

I have been a fan for years and last week's visit was no different. Great Food, amazing server and reasonably priced for the amazing food value. Seafood Salad and pasta with steak just amazing. I shall return as usual. John

I have been here many times. This time i was underwhelmed. My glassware was dirty. Food order took a long time and food was good but not as good as in the past