Best Steak Restaurants in Matteson

Exceeded our expectations. Food was amazing, service was exceptional. Dessert was delicious and drinks were incredible. This was our first experience and we chose it because we had decided to start picking a place we had never been once a month. Our choice did not disappoint! Everything was wonderful! Highly recommend! We can’t wait to try again.

Food was exceptionally good! Best meal I have had in a long time. Owners and staff were wonderful. What a great addition to that area! This place will be in our regular rotation!

Best Carrot cake anywhere - good steaks, great service (shout out to Jill) Definitely will come back.

Rosebud made my aunt’s birthday so special. Thank you for the incredible service.

We were a party of 3, with me being the only one having been here previously. Everyone was truly impressed with the service and especially the food. One in our party is just about to finish culinary school, and he in particular was very happy. He asked questions of our waitress which she answered completely, and with no hesitation. I know I learned a lot about food that evening (1/9/2025), just from listening. He ordered the aged strip steak, his mom ordered the filet mignon, and I ordered the New Zealand Rack of Lamb. All I can say is that all three of us had meals to remember (positive memories). I absolutely enjoyed my Lamb (which I ordered as "chef's choice" and it was perfect. The others also said their entire meals were perfect. I refer to Mr. Benny's as a hidden southside gem due to the fact that whenever fine dining is mentioned all anybody mentions are Northside or Downtown eateries, and I feel that Mr. Benny's is at least comparable to any of the others, but is far less known. Having been there before I know that no matter what I order it will be perfectly done. This is all that needs to be said.