Diners' Choice: Best Overall restaurants in Fort Collins

OpenTable

Updated December 05, 2024

Looking for the best overall restaurants in Fort Collins? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Bistro Nautile

4.9

4.9 (196)

$31 to $50

French

Fort Collins

About the restaurant

Bistro Nautile is a French-Influenced bistro owned and operated locally by three Fort Collins restaurateurs who care about food and the people that eat it. Our focus is on truly farm-fresh and sustainably sourced ingredients, meticulously prepared and presented in a comfortable atmosphere by servers who are equal parts professional and entertaining. Please join us for a dining experience where we will count you as a friend and hope that by the end of your time with us, you will have the same affection for our craft that we do.

Top review

Fred

Dined 4 days ago

Always a good time at Bistro Nautile. Thank you and we hope to see you again soon.

The Loveland Chophouse

4.9

4.9 (2305)

$31 to $50

Steakhouse

Loveland

About the restaurant

This 1930's-style restaurant balances a sophisticated and intimate dining experience with a casual and friendly atmosphere. Specializing in seafood and steak, the Chop House serves a traditional upscale menu and features weekly specials. The restaurant boasts an extensive wine and martini list, including our popular Moscow Mule, as well as local vodkas, whiskeys and liqueurs.

The Chop House is a gem found nestled among the brick buildings lining Historic Downtown Loveland. Reservations are always encouraged, especially for large parties. The Chop House's Roosevelt Room is perfect for hosting private events, such as seminars and business meetings or holiday parties and rehearsal dinners. Unique menu selections are provided specifically for Roosevelt Room guests to ensure their night is exceptional. The Chop House is the perfect place to celebrate with family and loved ones.

Top review

Skip

Dined 3 days ago

My filet mignon was cooked just like I it and my wife's salmon was excellent too!

Discover more

Popular dish

Lobster Ravioli

Chimney Park

4.8

4.8 (2941)

$50 and over

Contemporary American

Windsor

About the restaurant

Housed in historic downtown Windsor, Chimney Park’s original building from 1895 has undergone a recent renovation in 2022, the restaurant’s 15th anniversary. Chimney Park sources local, seasonal, and organic products from Colorado and the surrounding region. Whether it’s a special occasion, an evening with friends, or a nightly happy hour in the bar, Chimney Park offers an approachable, sophisticated atmosphere. The staff, cuisine, wine, and service are the core focuses that create hospitable and memorable experiences.

Please visit our website, www.chimneypark.com/mainmenu, for our most up-to-date menu offerings.

Top review

Anne

Dined 4 days ago

Chimney Park is a great place to celebrate special occasions.

Discover more

Experience

Christmas Eve Dinner 2024

Experience

New Year's Eve Dinner Menu 2024

Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar - Fort Collins

4.8

4.8 (2361)

$30 and under

Seafood

Fort Collins

About the restaurant

We don't take ourselves too seriously at Jax Fish House. Two things we do take seriously? The freshness and sustainability of our seafood. You know fresh fish when you see, smell, and taste it-and thanks to modern delivery technology, we bring in that freshy-fresh seven days a week. Sustainability is a little more complicated. Not all commercial fisheries are created equal. That's why we work closely with our suppliers and science-based organizations to ensure that every single thing we serve is responsibly sourced. We consider the stocks of the species we source to prevent overfishing and we work with suppliers who harvest in ways that have minimal impacts on marine environments.

Top review

John

Dined 1 day ago

Great time overall. The food was delicious and the service outstanding. Highly recommend the lobster bisque and the fried calamari was the best I’ve ever had. The restaurant does get a bit noisy if you want to have a quiet conversation however.

Discover more

Popular dish

Seafood Chowder

Experience

Feast of seven fishes

The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm

4.6

4.6 (836)

$31 to $50

American

Fort Collins

About the restaurant

Set in an 19th Century home, The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm is a casual restaurant focused on elevated country and healthy farm fare. With a ¼ acre and chicken coop in our backyard, The Farmhouse is proud to offer seasonal menus, made from scratch daily.

Top review

Nathaniel

Dined today

Very cool set up for restaurant and food/drinks were incredible. Best espresso martini I’ve ever had.

Discover more

Popular dish

Breakfast Burrito

Austin's American Grill - Old Town

4.7

4.7 (225)

$30 and under

American

Fort Collins

About the restaurant

Austin's American Grill is the quintessential taste of Colorado. With three great Fort Collin's locations-one in the heart of Old Town, another on Harmony Road and one in Greeley, we'll have you wondering why mom's food never tasted so good and when you can come back for more. Savory roasts and chicken cooked over an open flame in our front-of-the-house rotisserie. All-natural buffalo seasoned to perfection. Cornbread baked in iron skillets with honey butter. Signature cocktails sweetened with fresh-squeezed fruit juice. Plus, our decadent desserts are made fresh daily, giving you an excuse to stop in for a slice that reminds you of home. There's a reason Austin's is one of Northern Colorado's favorite destinations.

Top review

AnthonyVIP

Dined 3 days ago

Wonderful dinner. Enjoyed our waitress. Very personable and professional.

Blue Agave Grill - Fort Collins

4.7

4.7 (2305)

$30 and under

Mexican / Southwestern

Fort Collins

About the restaurant

We are a full service restaurant serving contemporary southwestern cuisine with a full service bar. We are a scratch kitchen with many gluten free options as well as a large margarita selection, house infused tequilas, and homemade sangria. Our outdoor seating accompanied by fire pits surrounds the historic art museum in old town Fort Collins CO. From guacamole made to order to our vibrant atmosphere, come on down and try a flight of our favorite drinks.

Top review

DaveVIP

Dined today

Jacob was a charming and attentive waiter. And I'm seven characters short of the minimum

Discover more

Popular dish

Tofu - Walnut Enchiladas

Mishawaka Amphitheatre Restaurant

4.7

4.7 (705)

$30 and under

American

Fort Collins

About the restaurant

The Mishawaka Amphitheatre boasts a full-service restaurant open Thursday-Monday. Dine on our scenic deck while observing the big horn sheep on the canyon hillside, or opt for our indoor seating, which features expansive bay windows for the same river and wildlife vistas. Our spotlighted Craft Micro Brewery, Odell Brewery from Fort Collins, CO, partners with us to feature the exclusive Mishawaka Ale. In addition to this, we offer a comprehensive bar selection, including a variety of craft beers, wines, and spirits.

PLEASE NOTE that reserving an outdoor spot guarantees a table outside but does not guarantee a table by the riverside. We offer a 10-minute grace period for reservations. Your party will be seated only when all members are present, due to our hour and a half limit on table occupancy. Should inclement weather arise, we cannot guarantee outdoor seating at the time of your reservation.

Our establishment is cashless. Kindly ensure you bring a debit or credit card.

Top review

Ollie

Dined on Nov 26, 2024

Mishawaka is amazing! Great views and food! Fun experience and excellent service!

Door 222 food & drink

4.7

4.7 (990)

$30 and under

Contemporary American

Loveland

About the restaurant

Door 222 Food and Drink is right in the heart of beautiful downtown Loveland. 222 serves an eclectic, chef driven seasonal menu with craft cocktails and large wine list in a comfortable unique setting.
We are open daily at 4pm, but closed on Mondays.

Reservations recommended, walk-ins accepted when seating is available.

Reservation disclaimer: We do not guarantee specific tables. We do not seat incomplete parties. There is a 15 minute grace period, if your party does not arrive within 15 minutes of your reservation, it will be canceled.

Your table will be reserved for 1 hour 30 minutes for parties of up to 2; 1 hour 45 minutes for parties of up to 4; 2 hours for parties over 6

Top review

Connie

Dined 1 day ago

We had a small Christmas get together at 222. Our wait person was excellent, she was very personable and gave us great recommendations for food choices. Four of us had not been there before The food was delicious and we will definitely be back.

Discover more

Ted's Sweetwater Grill

4.7

4.7 (21)

$30 and under

American

Windsor

About the restaurant

Everyone’s Family, at Ted’s Sweetwater Grill

Ted’s is the perfect gathering spot for friends and family, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes everyone feel at home.

At Ted’s, you’ll find neighborly customers, friendly staff, and hearty meals that satisfy every appetite. Choose from a variety of dining locations to suit your mood: enjoy a cozy meal in our dining room, unwind at the bar, or savor craft brews in our tap house. For a unique experience, dine on our floating dinner boats, relax by the fire pits, or soak in the ambiance on our scenic patio.

Come to Ted’s Sweetwater Grill for great food, great company, and great times. We can’t wait to see you soon!

Top review

MeganVIP

Dined 7 days ago

We met up with friends we had not seen in a year. Absolutley LOVED it! From the cozy welcoming exterior, to the fabulous food! We were impressed by everything! We are foodies and definitely will come back here. Highly reccomend! Loved the decor inside as well! I imagine the summer nights here are awesome on the patio! Thank you! The young lady that served us was wonderful, and numerous staff checking in as well! We tried the Cowboy Caviar 5 stars and the mushrooms for appitizers! Yummy! My hubby and I ordered the Honey glazed Salmon, it was DEEELICIOUS! Our friends did the Fish and chips which they both LOVED. And even the side salads were great! A must try if you are in the area!

Explore Diners' Choice best of Fort Collins

Explore more Diners' Choice lists