Best Authentic Restaurants in Cold Spring Harbor

My wife and I went to Jonathan's for a Valentine's Day dinner. The restaurant was packed but we were seated at the exact time of our reservation. I am mobility challenged as I recover from a fracture and the staff is sensitive to my issue. We shared the appetizers of oysters and tuna tartare, both really good. We had a delicious Valentine's Day cocktail based on Gin. My wife had the Branzino and I had the Stuffed Orata. The Orata was superbly deboned. Both entries were great. We shared a very unusual but quite delicious dessert of gelato and fruit and Balsamic Vinegar. It was a true finishing touch to a wonderful meal.While the cost was not small, it was worth everypenny

Amazing food and service! We love this restaurant and all the staff!

Eduardo’s Trattoria delivers in every level-outstanding Italian food, excellent service and a warm and inviting atmosphere. The fennel salad transported me back to Sicily and the raviolo was divine. We will definitely be back!

This was not our first visit to Mythos. They were busy but it took a good 10-15 minutes for someone to come by to take our drink order. Additionally, the wait staff does not tell you about off menu offerings unless you specifically ask. The food has always been great but the service, although friendly and polite, needs some polish.

My husband and I used to come here when we first got married, then life with two kids had us take a hiatus. It was always a Huntington favorite of ours so we chose to go back last weekend to celebrate our 26th wedding anniversary. What a meal! From the incredible butternut squash soup to the halibut in champagne sauce to the creme brûlée with pistachios and bananas, the meal was divine. My husband enjoyed the special cheeseburger followed by the Don Pedro desert! We will be back, and soon! The service was incredible, can't say enough good things about Cafe Buenos Aires!