Best Casual Restaurants in Mattituck

We really enjoyed our meal at the Halyard. We ordered several appetizers which consisted of calamari, squid, clams and the ricotta with honey. All of our appetizers were delicious. Compliments to the chef. We then ordered the chicken, short ribs and bolognese. All of our meals were so delicious. The short ribs were perfect for a chilly January evening. All of us were pretty full, but decided to try the desserts. Definitely worth saving room for dessert. The espresso creme brûlée is probably the best brûlée we have ever had. We also had the banana ice cream dessert which was fantastic. Definitely put this restaurant on your trip out east.

Sophie's is a true neighborhood gem. Delicious fish specials, great pizzas and friendly service.

I absolutely love it here! I always have a great experience. I come on the weekends to enjoy dinner listening to piano. Let's just say that bison is awesome! This place has the ambience and charm isn't really around anymore. The vibe is so relaxed and you can just check out of your thoughts for the evening and enjoy the moment where you are. Service is great! The bartender is excellent. 

Nice to be able to order whatever I want as a person with celiac disease and know that everything was gluten free.

Great experience. Service and food first class. Pricey but well worth it. Hand duck, wife had chicken scallapini , son had bass. All outstanding. Some of the best service I ever had