Best Date Night Restaurants in Middle Island

Artisan always provides an excellent dining experience.

My boyfriend and I had an EXCELLENT experience at Tellers, celebrating his birthday. Everything from the cocktails to the entrees to the sides was delicious. We started with a dirty martini and a Tellers cosmo—both made to the smoothest, well-balanced perfection. For appetizers my boyfriend ordered a half dozen Blue Point oysters, which he said were out of this world, and I split with him the Short Rib Bone Marrow Agnolotti which was divine. For entrees, he ordered the Cowgirl Ribeye, which he couldn’t put his fork down to finish, and I ordered the Tellers Delmonico, wherein the truffle butter sauce was out of this world. For sides we split Creamed Spinach and Scalloped Parmesan Potatoes which held their own against our dreamy entrees. The Crème Brûlée was delivered with a lovely Happy Birthday decoration and has to have been the best we’ve ever had. We even received a lovely note with a gift card for a future use to celebrate! It was overall an amazing experience with food and service that lived up to our expectations. We will be going back!

Had a great first dining experience at Farm Italy. Food and service were excellent. Will definitely be back

Amazing food amazing ambience amazing staff! Will be back

I really loved the overall experience. Great cocktail and wine menu. Quality wines by the glass which is nice when you don’t want a full bottle but want the best! The staff work like a cohesive team to deliver great service. I had the Porterhouse which was perfect. My son actually had the Wagyu on the hot stone that was on the appetizer menu. He enjoyed cooking it on the stone and of course with all the sides made a wonderful dinner that was a bit different ! Overall - looking forward to going back soon.