Best Fine Dining Restaurants in West Indy

Wendi's a great server that we've been requesting for years. The restaurant was busy with Valentine's Day guests but she and the staff did a great job of taking care of us. M&S is a mainstay for us before or after a show by the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra as it's just a short walk around the circle plus a block to Illinois and Market.

Mitch took care of us and made the Valentines experience next level. Cudos to him, great kid , always there if we needed something, but not overbearing. We feel that’s the difference between Capital grill and Rubys. Ruby’s service people are too much!

Friday night dinner. Sat in the bar area. Sarah was our very attentive server. Filet for myself and Chicken Caesar salad for the date. We added the mac and cheese (a MUST!) and the truffle wedges. All items were great! Filet was cooked perfectly to medium. Tender. Great flavor and not overseasoned. Top quality meat. One of the few steakhouses where you get what you pay for. Worth it every time! Phenomenal wine list, both by the glass and by the bottle. One of the few places in town with a) a great wine selection; and b) reasonably priced wines by the glass. Desert menu was uninspiring (maybe because we were full?), but you might enjoy some of the offerings. Shout out to Steven, the busser (I believe) for being engaging and friendly with us. He was multi-tasking like crazy, and doing so while being nice. Love Tony’s. My favorite steakhouse in town. Great people work for great people, and you’ll more than likely find a top notch experience here.

A five star review isn’t anywhere near enough for our experience at Prime47. I don’t think I’ve ever had better service and every interaction with the staff was so polite and professional. We had an amazing evening and left feeling like royalty. Oh and the food is incredible too ;)

I brought my girlfriend here for her 20th birthday and we definitely have to come back in September for my 20th. Our service from Francesco was amazing, he never let our glasses go empty, gave great conversation, and he was already there anytime we needed. We ordered the salmon and short rib which were both delicious and cooked perfectly. Overall the best part of the experience was when Francesco made the Tableside Bananas Foster, not only was it the best bananas foster I’ve ever had, I loved how he made it in front of us.