Best Restaurants with a Happy Hour in Mattituck

What a delightful night! Delicious food and drinks and our server, Gina, was so helpful and food savvy…a perfect blend of friendly and informative! We had the opportunity to speak with John Armenio, the manager, who graciously introduced himself at our table and was genuinely interested in hearing about our experience at the restaurant. The staff spoke highly about the owners and the place…a nice tribute to the Halston. We had the Shrimp Scampi over risotto and the baby-back ribs..both delicious! Starter was a delicately dressed caesar salad..perfection. We can not wait to return!

Our evening at The Waterlot was wonderful from beginning to end! We were 2 couples. The service was top notch and the food was delicious. Both couples had the Caesar salad for 2 for an app which was prepared at the table-excellent! My husband and I both had the beef tenderloin (mine with a delicious blue cheese crust)—they perfectly cooked. We had sides of fries, roasted potatoes and steamed mixed vegetables and all were great for sharing among the 4 of us. The other couple had short ribs and cod and were very happy with their choices. We finished the evening off by sharing the delicious carrot cake for dessert. We are so glad that the Waterlot is back —we will definitely be going back! Shout out to our servers Alec and Warleo and to Brent who we were happy to see back in Bermuda!

Delicious meal & great service! And the ambiance can’t be beat- beautiful setting.

I loved the food I ordered oysters Cesar salad my favorite tomahawk steak I Iike how they sliced on the side table, bottle of wine and the service was amazing, we got a nice experience with our server Andres very friendly he made us feel at home we’ll be back 👏

Prime is our go to for special occasions, family events or just date night. The food is great, ample portions and wonderful staff.