Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in East Islip

Great meal, Service was spot on. Food and drinks were great. Always a great time at the Lakehouse. Specials tonight were great. We will be back soon.

We made a last minute reservation and were pleasantly greeted upon arrival. We love to sit near the fireplace, however there was not an available table in that area. Instead we were seated upstairs which was such a pleasant experience! It was much more quiet and formal. Our waiter was so kind, attentive and funny! The food was 10/10 as per usual. We enjoy the crab cake, baked clams, porterhouse for two, shishito peppers and lobster mac; it’s our “go-to” dinner. It’s always a pleasure to dine at Tellers whether it’s for a casual dinner or holiday celebration.

Everyone from the hostess to the water guys, to the bartender, to the waitress were friendly and couldn’t do enough. Delicious filet and mashed potatoes and creamed spinach sides. We also had the halibut special, also delicious. They do everything well.

My wife and I had Valentine’s Day Dinner here. The food was unbelievable and the oysters were perfect.

Excellent time as always, great food, good value...