Best Romantic Restaurants in Amityville

Delicious, as always! We love the yin/yang chocolate dessert fondue

The James has definitely become one of my favorite restaurants! Every staff member is so incredibly nice and helpful! I have difficult food restrictions, and the chef couldn’t be more accommodating. Matt, the Manager is so friendly, and kind, as was Carlos, our server! Perfect way to celebrate my birthday!

I had the best anniversary dinner at Toto’s last night! We sat in the angel room and it gave me the feeling like I was eating over someone grandmothers home, the ambiance was immaculate. There was a man who started off on the keyboard and eventually sang too and it was so nice. It was the perfect background music, I hate when the music is so loud you can’t even have a conversation. I got the white margarita and my husband got the smoked old fashion. The presentation of the old fashion was so cool! For an appetizer we got the French onion soup and the Brussels sprouts both on the specials list. The Brussels sprouts were the best I’ve ever had! They were brussels sprouts, caramelized onions, balsamic vinegar glaze and walnuts. The French onion soup was also really good, me and my husband shared it. For our entree we got the prime steak for two and it was cooked perfectly. We also had the mashed potatoes for our side. I was so full I couldn’t eat another bite but my husband got the carrot cake and he fought to finish it all. We will absolutely be back soon!

Christmas day menu had so many items to choose from. Everything was hot and delicious. The server was very friendly and remembered everything. Atmosphere was packed noise was loud but ok and it was so nice and warm. We felt cozy. Had a wonderful experience for our first Christmas Day meal out. We came for Mother's Day and had the same experience which is why I continue to go back. Love this place.

What a gem!!! Great festive decor, a crowded spot. Even with a late reservation. The food was top tier the zucchini appetizer was decadent in every way. Our meal was hot served promptly and had delicious rich flAvor. we can't wait return!