Best Historic Restaurants in Gates Mills

The food and service were outstanding. The coffee was lukewarm at best, but the caipirinhas were fantastic. We’ll be back.

Impressive and our first time being here. The food was spot on as well as the water service. I liked that there were eyes on the dining room. Our server messed up on delivering the sides but brought us mashed potatoes on the house while we waited,except we didn’t get them until one of the managers came over to ask how things were. They then came immediately and were delicious. Beet salad was amazing and the bread was awesome. Great mix of flavors. Everybody at the table loved their dishes. We will be back!

That grilled cheese with tomato bisque is killer great for lunch. My Mom said her burger was super and whatever bacon they put it on was top notch e. The fries are fried and seasoned perfectly. This is a great choice for a nice casual lunch. They probably have the best by-the-glass wine selection of any restaurant I have seen in a long time. The special touch? On the back of the menu they share the names of the staff from the Chef to the front of house servers. I love that they show that level of respect to their employees and that they want the diner to know who is making and serving food. I will definitely put Oddfellows in heavy rotation. Thank you again for a great ladies’ lunch.

We had a 4 generation dinner from my 91 year old father to my 3 1/2 year old grandson. Great service by our server Danielle and great food as always.