Best Historic Restaurants in Yorktown Heights

We had Thanksgiving dinner there, which was festive, filling and flavorful! Note to self: never reserve for the last seating on a holiday - they always run out of key dishes. The soup was gone, as were the stuffed mushrooms as well as the apple strudel - not to mention the Brussels sprouts being silently replaced by string beans. Plenty of other choices, but not always what we would have selected an hour earlier. Note to the restaurant owners: swap out the oil filled, open, unprotected flame votives with wax candles in proper votive holders (or battery LEDs, they make gorgeously flickering realistic ones now). Especially in an historic structure with ancient chestnut wood beams. We watched in horror as a staffer cleared a table near us - accidentally lighting a guest's napkin on fire. It burst into flames, was thrown to the floor, stomped on, more flames and then picked up again, still flaming and shoved into a coffee cream pitcher. A lucky ending to a reckless decor decision. Would we return? Absolutely, for an earlier sitting - and hopefully safer decor.

Sandy our server has been there for years and is our favorite. She takes ownership of her job and makes the meal awesome …food was great and we love coming when visiting WP

Lovely dinner, a favorite for special occasions, date nights and family celebrations. It was our son's birthday and the staff brought a Ferris wheel of little puff pastries and pots of chocolate and Chantilly cream. The service was very attentive and the food was delicious. The lighting is low, but lovely. The noise is a bit much -- high ceilings and tile walls and pillars, which, I don't know what you can do with that. But, overall, I recommend 3 Westerly for a nice night out.

A wonderful experience in all respects. It was lovely to have a quiet delicious meal.

A great dining experience. The food was excellent. In particular, the roasted chicken breast. The service was equally excellent. The ambiance was outstanding. And, the live jazz, performed by Kristina Koller, made the evening perfect.