Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in East Indy

Great food and service Seated immediately at reservation time Steaks cooked perfectly

Shrimp Cocktail will clear your sinuses but it is a must have! 60 day dry aged NY was melt in your mouth delicious! Don’t skip the dessert!

Everything was Fabulous as always!! Love the Huse restaurants

What a gem in downtown Pendleton!! The atmosphere is classy but not intimidating. You can have a conversation with your table of guests without having to talk over loud background music. The food is amazing! Authentic Italian cuisine that will make you want to come back again and again. Not only is the Cheese Wheel Pasta an experience like no other it is absolutely delicious. Fresh ingredients all around and homemade pasta make Catello's a cut above. The service was excellent. The staff is knowledgeable, friendly and the right amount of attentive. An added bonus is the grocery area at the back of the restaurant. Authentic Italian meats and cheeses sliced to order, fresh pasta and sauces, homemade gelato and other desserts are available for purchase. Catello's is absolutely worth the drive and we can't wait to go back!

The decor is always amazing. It’s like being immersed in a winter wonderland. The chicken velvet soup is the best! Our server was prompt. The portions were plenty so we had to take our cake home. I would highly recommend either the millionaire or red velvet cakes!