Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Sanibel

Everything was great! Caitlyn , our server was right on top of everything! Oysters were absolutely perfect! Our entrees were great! Never felt rushed, our family enjoyed going to Connor’s. Definitely recommend!!

First time eating at a Tommy Bahama. We got The coconut shrimp as it is their signature dish and it did not disappoint. There was live music and the young man was good but it added to the noise level making it hard to converse. My husband got the grouper he said it was the best he ever had. My son got the red snapper. He said the same. The crab bisque is outstanding. Very lively atmosphere. My only complaint was the noise level. Our waiter Josh was fun and came and sang along with me at the table to a Tom Petty song the musician was singing to. We will definitely go back.

Excellent meal. Parmesan chicken and the Spaghetti (actually Bucatini) and meatballs were fabulous and portions were very generous. Our server, Nicole, was very attentive and helped. The parking was the only problem because lighting is too dim particularly at the driveway. They had valet service but no signage to alert drivers as they enter.

Wonderful evening all around! The food/drinks were excellent as well as the presentation and service.

My wife and I had dinner at Sails and sat at the bar. If you haven’t dined at Sails and sat at the bar, it is a wonderful experience and it is our favorite place in the restaurant to dine when there are just the two of us. Our server, Yesar, was outstanding and made the dinner even more enjoyable. He made sure everything was handled perfectly. We shared the Grilled Octopus and not only was the Octopus cooked perfectly, but the serving size was more than enough for two people. Our main courses were the Lobster Ravioli and Linguine/Clams and were both excellent. While the food was outstanding, the martinis perfect, but even the check-in was special. Such a friendly and welcoming process. Our thanks to all of those at Sails who made our evening special.