Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Siesta Key
Price
- $30 and under
- $31 to $50
- $50 and over
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
25 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- MMary CatherineTahoe / Reno Area •4 reviews5.0Dined 1 day ago11 am reservations were enjoyed by the six of us. Sunday(s), street parking and the nearby garage parking are free and we took full advantage of that "bonus". By noon, this wonderful restaurant was "hopping" with customers. Our menu selections were all served hot, fresh and delicious. The Scallops Casimiro and Stuffed Mushrooms are a tasty choice for starters. The 1905 Salad is a wonderful dish and this delicious salad can be shared between two people. And finally the Cuban Sandwich -- beyond delicious! A large sandwich so bring your appetite. Our server MAX was outstanding. Very attentive, but not aggressively attentive. Max gave us just enough time in between ordering and enjoying our selections but was quietly attentive to refill water glasses and asked if anyone wanted refills of beverages. Extremely good server - if I could give MAX 10 stars, I would! Value - expect to pay about $25 - $30 per person (beverage included.) TIP: Book your reservation(s) at least 2 weeks ahead of time and enjoy the 11 am time slot for a beautiful brunch. Bring your appetites! Sidewalk tables are available for those who wish to enjoy their Columbia experience with their fur baby or for those just wanting to sit outside and soak up some great Florida sunshine. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!More infoColumbia Restaurant - SarasotaPrice: Moderate• Spanish• Sarasota•4.8
- JJessVIPHawaii •19 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoFirst visit to Sarasota- we frequent the Fort Myers location more often. Pleasantly surprised by the elevated experience. Haley- our waitress was polite, prompt, friendly - flawless. The food was perfect - an issue we seem to have in FM with undercooked filet was not an issue here. We ordered medium and got medium. Wine selection was good; margaritas were awesome. Would like to see an expended red wine list with Paso Robles wines someday but still good choices imo. Overall a wonderful night and a great experience. Would go back if in this area again.More infoConnors Steak & Seafood - SarasotaPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Siesta Key•4.7
- FFrankNew Jersey •1 review5.0Dined 3 days agoDinner was fantastic our waitress Marren did a fantastic job and was very attentive. The wine service was wonderful and great choices. He started with a gnocchi special. That was wonderful. We split that with three people as an appetizer. My wife and I had the linguine Pescatore, which was fantastic. Great pasta, and loaded with seafood. Her friend had the eggplant which was wonderful. Both dishes were so filled that we took leftovers home and there was no room for dessert unfortunately. Their dessert menu is delightful and next time I will have to make room.More infoCafe GabbianoPrice: Moderate• Italian• Siesta Key•4.7
- BBradfordGreater Boston •13 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoIndigenous continues to be our favorite restaurant in Sarasota. We have been 5 or 6 times now and it is consistently excellent. Food is delicious and is comes from a variety of sources. Always fresh and tasty. The service is extraordinary. Although we are only seasonal residents of Sarasota, dinner at Indigenous is always a must for us.More infoIndigenousPrice: Expensive• American• Sarasota•4.7
- DDoreenVIPGreater Boston •130 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoAbsolutely delicious Tried something new and was not disappointed I got the salt crusted sea bass. It was prepared table side Amazing as was the yellow tail special, the cappuccino and the ammerato gelato YumMore infoSardinia SarasotaPrice: Moderate• Italian• Sarasota•4.8
Discover best neighborhood gem restaurants in Siesta Key
Discover the charm of neighborhood gems in Siesta Key, Tampa / Central Florida West, Sarasota / Bradenton area with our curated list of local favorite restaurants. These dining spots are celebrated for their unique ambiance, offering a cozy and intimate setting perfect for a special evening out. Renowned for sourcing local ingredients, the restaurants in this location pride themselves on a menu that blends traditional and contemporary flavors, reflecting the rich culinary heritage of the area. From exquisite Italian cuisine to innovative modern dishes, each restaurant ensures a memorable dining experience with exceptional service and a meticulously selected wine list. The dining scene in Siesta Key and surrounding areas is vibrant and diverse, featuring eateries that are often described as hidden treasures of the neighborhood. Whether you're a local or a visitor, these neighborhood gems provide a delightful exploration of taste and tradition in one of Florida's most picturesque settings.