Best Restaurants with Great Beer in Reynoldsburg

One of the few downtown restaurants we'll still go out of our way to visit, especially with the insane parking. The restaurant itself has an awesome historic charm. It is on the nosier side, but that's the only negative. Our last visit we had walleye, which was exceptional and a corned beef reuben which was decent. The service is always excellent.

We enjoyed the 2025 Valentine's menu. It came with an app, main, and desert for just $36 bucks which is kinda wild and affordable in my opinion. The ambience is stunning, just a really cozy, dim, romantic feel. Not too noisy, and despite being a full restaurant on one of the busiest days of the year, it felt surprisingly intimate with the use of cloth curtains partitioning the space into smaller sections. The appetizers were fantastic, I had the shrimp gumbo and my girlfriend had the wedge salad. For the main course I had the crab linguine Alfredo which was incredible and had an absurd amount of crab (in a very good way). My girlfriend had the pork and it was so tender, served right on the shank for an impressive display and large portion. Dessert was the only bummer. They were out of tiramisu so our options were a beer float or a s'mores brownie. I loved my float, but the brownie was dry, hard, and I make better ones out of a box. Overall, incredible meal though, super affordable and with some cocktails and beers it was still well below our Vday date budget. Finally need to note that our server was a joy! She was super informative about the menu, very personable and fun. Attentive, really just all the things you want from your service. We will be back for sure!

The Arch City Tavern Burger might be my all-time favorite! And the Moscow Mule? So grid!

We had such a nice waitress which really made our Valentine’s Day dinner enjoyable. Great chocolate covered strawberry martini and delicious hush puppies!! It was nice that the outside fire pit was lit creating a warm feeling inside on a cold night.

Best brewed craft beers around. Good menu with wide variety of food. Everything I've had has been delicious. Went for Super Bowl so noise was more than most other times I've been there. The pizza is very different but so good. Thicker crust but crispy. Yum.