Restaurants near Starfish Beach House by Vacation Rental Pros

We went here for the Miracle Pop-up Bar, one of our annual traditions. The festive drinks are always super fun and delicious, and their food menu is great as ever. Both my husband and I had a couple of their vegan options which were delicious, and the other two with us had the mussels and the chicken sandwich. Portion sizes were so much bigger than I remembered! It’s always busy, especially during the Christmas season so reservations are an absolute must. Fun little perk: they gave us special Miracle beanies as a thank you for making a reservation!

I wanted to enjoy a Thanksgiving dinner while on vacation with my wife and mother. After checking the options online, Atlantic Grille looked like the best move. I’m glad to say it 100% was the best decision I could have made. Perfect service and excellent food. Everyone form the hostess to our waiter was fantastic and very welcoming. The waiter even took the time to get some pictures of us on the deck. Great experience, we’ll be back when in town.

We had a beautiful Thanksgiving dinner at the Columbia. Our waitress was excellent, even though she was very busy she made sure to check on us frequently and attend to all of our needs. I don’t remember her name but it was her birthday on Thanksgiving. The restaurant was decorated beautifully as always at this time of the year. We had a great table in the enclosed patio. It was pretty noisy but that is expected with all the large groups and just adds to the holiday atmosphere! We come here often as we live here and are never disappointed!

Old City House is my favorite restaurant in all of St Augustine. It has that perfect old world ambience. The courtyard is quaint and romantic. The food is absolutely delicious and lavishly decorated. This restaurant also makes the best margarita in town! The wait staff is top shelf. I can’t wait to go back very soon. I highly recommend this hidden gem of our beloved St Augustine 💜

We have been here before and loved it. This time my duck was excellent but my friend had a poor quality steak. Server noticed that he did not eat much. She showed Owner who totally made it right! Gave him a whole take home dinner as we had to leave. That is customer care at its best!