Restaurants near Sydney Lyric Theatre

Great staff and food. Great experience overall. Recommended!

Wonderful early dinner with an old friend, pasta and veal were our highlights. Service very good.

Tucked beneath the bustling streets of the Sydney CBD, Neptune's Grotto is the latest venture from the powerhouse hospitality group behind some of the city’s most beloved dining spots—Clam Bar and Pellegrino 2000—and it’s nothing short of spectacular. An underground Italian eatery with an effortlessly cool, intimate vibe, this new arrival is a masterclass in creating a dining experience that feels both exclusive and utterly inviting. Step inside, and you’re immediately wrapped in warmth. The dim glow of low lighting and plush banquettes invite you to settle in, and the hum of conversation feels like a secret well-kept. It’s the perfect antidote to the city’s relentless energy—a sanctuary where the only thing louder than the ambience is the symphony of flavours on your plate. Neptune's Grotto is more than just a meal; it’s an experience. A place to escape, indulge, and revel in the magic of beautifully crafted Italian food. It’s a must-visit.

The service was great and the renovated restaurant was very pleasant to be at. The food was good but the staff and the environment made it really enjoyable.

The kitchen shut at 2:30pm so that our dining was a little restricted