Shelter Island Restaurants
Make a free reservation
Visa Dining Collection
Get exclusive access to primetime reservations at some of the country's hottest restaurants
See what locals rave about in Shelter Island
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- CCarol KoschekaVIPSouth Carolina •33 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoWe really enjoyed our meal at the Halyard. We ordered several appetizers which consisted of calamari, squid, clams and the ricotta with honey. All of our appetizers were delicious. Compliments to the chef. We then ordered the chicken, short ribs and bolognese. All of our meals were so delicious. The short ribs were perfect for a chilly January evening. All of us were pretty full, but decided to try the desserts. Definitely worth saving room for dessert. The espresso creme brûlée is probably the best brûlée we have ever had. We also had the banana ice cream dessert which was fantastic. Definitely put this restaurant on your trip out east.More infoThe Halyard Restaurant at Sound ViewPrice: Expensive• American• Greenport•4.4
- OTOpenTable DinerNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoEverything was delicious! Service, 6 courses of small plates and ambiance.More infoNoah'sPrice: Expensive• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.5
- SSophieNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 7 days agoWonderful food & service! Delicious, highly recommend!More infoOlive Branch CafePrice: Expensive• Mediterranean• Greenport•4.9
- YYasminVIPNew York City •82 reviews5.0Dined on Dec 25, 2024Great holiday evening! Maria Paulis was fantastic! Professional, knowledgeable, attentive and kind. The food was great too.More infoVine Street CafePrice: Very Expensive• American• Shelter Island•4.6
- MmaureenNew Orleans / Louisiana •13 reviews5.0Dined on Dec 24, 2024Christmas Eve dinner we were greeted by Emily. She was warm and friendly and made us feel welcome. Our server Valerie Was delightful and professional. She recommended the duck special and it was delicious. Very enjoyable Christmas Eve!More infoClaudio's Tavern & GrillPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Greenport•4.2
Trending dishes in Shelter Island
Explore dishes that diners are raving about
Restaurant experiences trending in New York State
Frequently asked questions
The best reviewed restaurant in Shelter Island is Vine Street Cafe