next to Casa Monica Hotel Side of St. George st. two minutes from Lincolnville","executiveChef":null,"entertainment":null,"cateringDetails":null,"website":"http://www.oldcityhouseinn.com/","hoursOfOperation":"Dinner\n Mon–Thu 5:00 pm–9:00 pm\n Fri, Sat 4:30 pm–10:00 pm\n Sun 4:30 pm–8:00 pm","parkingDetails":"Public parking by the lightner museum free daily after 5:00 pm","parkingInfo":"Street Parking","dressCode":"Casual Dress","crossStreet":"king st. & Cordova st.","additionalDetails":["Banquet","Bar Dining","Bar/Lounge","Beer","Corkage Fee","Full Bar","Non-Smoking","Outdoor Smoking Area","Private Room","Wine"],"paymentOptions":["AMEX","Discover","Mastercard","Visa"],"type":"GuestCenter","stateId":1,"maxAdvanceDays":90,"rooms":null,"editorialLists":{"correlationId":"e9ca50cc-297a-46ca-8ff5-1d36d31cd808","lists":[],"__typename":"EditorialLists"},"mostRecentReview":{"reviews":[{"text":"A wonderful Anniversary dinner. We hadn’t been for a while and it was as delicious as we remembered","__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"}],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResults"},"photos":{"galleryV3":{"photos":[{"title":"","pid":25060673,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/25060673-1","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":3024,"height":3024,"timestamp":"2017-08-18T01:46:46Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":25044067,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/25044067-1","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"exterior","width":512,"height":512,"timestamp":"2017-08-04T01:50:44Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":25060674,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/25060674-1","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":3024,"height":3024,"timestamp":"2017-08-18T01:46:48Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":"","pid":25060675,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/25060675-1","creator":null,"source":"Restaurant","category":"food","width":4128,"height":2322,"timestamp":"2017-08-18T01:46:51Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":28477216,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/28477216-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"interior","width":3024,"height":4032,"timestamp":"2019-12-17T17:13:52Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":26456686,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/26456686-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"interior","width":4032,"height":3024,"timestamp":"2019-06-22T03:17:52Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":25886382,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/25886382-0","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"interior","width":3024,"height":4032,"timestamp":"2018-11-06T19:29:41Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":74129051,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/74129051-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"exterior","width":3024,"height":4032,"timestamp":"2025-03-04T12:24:04Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":65102226,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/65102226-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"exterior","width":3024,"height":4032,"timestamp":"2024-05-19T01:26:14Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":76415315,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/76415315-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"exterior","width":3024,"height":4032,"timestamp":"2025-04-06T18:42:54Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":66739409,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/66739409-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"exterior","width":1284,"height":1737,"timestamp":"2024-07-19T22:14:16Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":66739407,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/66739407-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"exterior","width":1284,"height":1737,"timestamp":"2024-07-19T22:14:11Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":50569361,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/50569361-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"interior","width":4032,"height":3024,"timestamp":"2022-12-09T14:03:09Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":49573000,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/49573000-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"interior","width":1570,"height":2094,"timestamp":"2022-09-18T12:14:43Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"},{"title":null,"pid":48176336,"url":"//resizer.otstatic.com/v3/photos/48176336-1","creator":null,"source":"Diner","category":"interior","width":3024,"height":4032,"timestamp":"2022-05-14T23:29:13Z","__typename":"GalleryPhotoV3"}],"__typename":"GalleryPhotosV3","totalCount":475,"categories":[{"name":"food","count":434,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"exterior","count":24,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"drink","count":10,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"interior","count":6,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"},{"name":"other","count":1,"__typename":"PhotoCategories"}],"showMosaic":true},"profile":{"large":{"url":"https://images.otstatic.com/prod/25044067/1/large.jpg","width":640,"height":640,"__typename":"Thumbnail"},"__typename":"RestaurantProfile"},"__typename":"RestaurantPhotos"},"address":{"line1":"115 Cordova St","line2":"","state":"FL","city":"St. Augustine","postCode":"32084","country":"United States","__typename":"Address"},"contactInformation":{"formattedPhoneNumber":"(904) 826-0113","__typename":"RestaurantContactInformation"},"metro":{"metroId":83,"statistics":{"restaurantCount":1941,"__typename":"MetroStatistics"},"urls":{"premiumLandingLink":{"link":"https://www.opentable.ae/premium?m=83","__typename":"PageLink"},"__typename":"MetroUrls"},"displayName":"Jacksonville","__typename":"Metro"},"timeZone":{"offsetInMinutes":-240,"__typename":"RestaurantTimeZone"},"coordinates":{"latitude":29.8913519,"longitude":-81.31343,"mapUrl":"https://maps.googleapis.com/maps/api/staticmap?key=AIzaSyBHDlZeuOrKam8hwQCouMlwI-hNAqacPtM&size=288x144&language=en-US&markers=color%3A0x6AADCC%7C29.8913519%2C-81.31343&signature=ZoN6Z-4b-zCGEZxMM7upwFrTuA0=","__typename":"GeographicCoordinates"},"priceBand":{"currencySymbol":"$","priceBandId":3,"name":"$31 to $50","__typename":"PriceBand"},"statistics":{"recentReservationCount":7,"reviews":{"allTimeTextReviewCount":2242,"showReviews":true,"totalNumberOfReviews":193,"verifiedReviews":true,"ratingBasedOn":"RecentReviews","awards":[{"location":"Jacksonville / Northeast Florida","name":"Romantic","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"Jacksonville / Northeast Florida","name":"Contemporary American","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Best Overall","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Best Food","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Best Service","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Best Ambiance","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Best Value","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Neighborhood gem","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Great for fine wines","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Great for outdoor dining","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Romantic","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"},{"location":"St. Augustine","name":"Good for special occasions","__typename":"RestaurantReviewAward"}],"ratings":{"count":193,"overall":{"rating":4.8,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"ambience":{"rating":4.8,"count":193,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"food":{"rating":4.8,"count":193,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"service":{"rating":4.8,"count":193,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"value":{"rating":4.6,"count":193,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"noise":{"rating":2,"count":193,"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRating"},"overallRatingsDistribution":{"one":0,"two":3,"three":5,"four":22,"five":163,"__typename":"OverallRatingsDistribution"},"__typename":"ReviewStatisticsRatings"},"changeOfConceptType":"","changeOfConceptDateTimeUtc":null,"categories":[{"category":{"name":"Good for special occasions","key":"SpecialOccasions","__typename":"ReviewCategory"},"__typename":"ReviewCategoryWithCount"},{"category":{"name":"Charming","key":"Charming","__typename":"ReviewCategory"},"__typename":"ReviewCategoryWithCount"},{"category":{"name":"Neighborhood gem","key":"NeighborhoodGem","__typename":"ReviewCategory"},"__typename":"ReviewCategoryWithCount"}],"__typename":"ReviewStatistics"},"__typename":"RestaurantStatistics"},"primaryCuisine":{"cuisineId":"2b0938a7-b430-48b2-bf04-045bbe6c3bb2","name":"Contemporary American","__typename":"Cuisine"},"experiences":[],"cuisines":[{"name":"Contemporary American","__typename":"Cuisine"}],"macro":{"macroId":290,"__typename":"Macro"},"features":{"permanentlyClosed":null,"waitlistV2Only":false,"waitlistV2Enabled":false,"networkNonBookable":null,"prioritySeatingEnabled":null,"bar":true,"counter":false,"highTop":false,"outdoor":true,"optsOutOfLoyaltyRedemptions":null,"giftsURLs":null,"giftsEnabled":null,"suppressDinerGeneratedContent":null,"reservationMaxPartySize":6,"inPremiumMarketplace":false,"paymentProcessor":null,"visaDiningProgram":null,"chaseDiningProgram":null,"dinerAiEnabled":true,"subtype":null,"visaEventsProgram":null,"__typename":"RestaurantFeatures"},"whyPremiumMarketplace":null,"neighborhood":{"neighborhoodId":869,"name":"St. Augustine","coordinates":{"latitude":29.892306,"longitude":-81.313881,"__typename":"GeographicCoordinates"},"__typename":"Neighborhood"},"hasTakeout":false,"hasDeliveryPartners":false,"hasDeliveryDirect":false,"hasWhiteLabelDelivery":false,"orderOnlineLink":null,"whiteLabelDelivery":null,"deliveryPartners":[],"facebookUrl":null,"localization":{"address":"en-US","__typename":"RestaurantLocalization"},"country":{"countryId":"US","__typename":"Country"},"popularDishes":{"correlationId":"5d81bd3b-447c-4f53-aed4-ddf5e7ef4ad3","dishes":[{"dishId":"138553-3e385c88783c9bb605344e8d2d355de8","name":"Vegetable Lasagna","description":"Cauliflower Zucchini Squash Carrots Onions Sweet Peppers Baby Spinach and Homemade Marinara","reviewCount":9,"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109782164-130010268803","text":"Celebrated our 20th anniversary here. \nFood and ambience were excellent.\nVegetable lasagna was best ever! Would love the recipe!!!\nOnly downside was that we mentioned celebrating our 20th anniversary special occasion, but it was not recognized.\nAll else was great. Free parking, too.","submittedDateTime":"2024-06-09T12:30:44Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":null,"isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"OT","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":73,"endIndex":90,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109783172-130012684863","text":"Great for a date night! Food was incredible. The vegetable lasagna was the best!","submittedDateTime":"2024-06-05T13:19:32Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"EllenS","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"ES","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":51,"endIndex":68,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109782788-130072706493","text":"Filet was excellent. Vegetable lasagna was very good but not what we expected. It was not so much layered veggies but a soufflé filling. We enjoyed dinner, however the pound cake for dessert we would pass on next time.","submittedDateTime":"2024-05-22T10:58:35Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Suppertogether","isVip":true,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","initials":"S","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":21,"endIndex":38,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109778868-170126545997","text":"Best Restaurant in St Augustine, the vegetable lasagna is incredible!!","submittedDateTime":"2024-01-15T04:16:52Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":null,"isVip":true,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","initials":"OT","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":37,"endIndex":54,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109779318-160055393546","text":"Old City House never disappoints. Server was attentive, chef’s soup and dinner specials were delicious. And they serve our favorite dessert/ crème brûlée .\n\nHighly trvommend.","submittedDateTime":"2023-10-13T10:48:07Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"MaryC","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PUMPKIN","initials":"MC","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":64,"endIndex":68,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"}],"photos":[{"photoMetaData":{"title":null,"photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/71460460.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"medium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/medium/1/71460460.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/71460460.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/1/71460460.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"DishPhoto"}],"__typename":"Dish"},{"dishId":"138553-989c53d2519ef94c252182612937ce58","name":"Beef Tenderloin","description":"Served with Vegetables Gratin Potatoes and Topped with Herb and Truffle Butter","reviewCount":14,"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109782225-100047352420","text":"Our waiter, service & food was outstanding! Our waiter was very attentive & the our steak was cooked perfectly.","submittedDateTime":"2024-06-02T22:20:21Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Peggy","isVip":null,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","initials":"P","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":84,"endIndex":89,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109780747-170156096467","text":"The food was excellent, best steak I had in a long time. The setting was romantic and quaint. She crab soup was amazing and service was top notch. I would highly recommend this spot as a must date night with your loved ones.","submittedDateTime":"2024-02-17T13:03:14Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"MichaelG","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"MG","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":29,"endIndex":34,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109781186-170207114807","text":"Everything was great except steak was not cooked as ordered. Service was great… atmosphere great… food was very good. I also love that they’re flexible with substitutions. Will go back","submittedDateTime":"2024-02-20T17:56:49Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":null,"isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"OT","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":28,"endIndex":33,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109781472-190031996519","text":"The Pork chops and Steak were excellent but the service was a little slow. The atmosphere was quite nice and we felt special in their lovely dining room","submittedDateTime":"2024-02-18T01:22:41Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Bill","isVip":null,"profileColor":"PLUM","initials":"B","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":19,"endIndex":24,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109779830-140026365064","text":"Celebrated my birthday here and it was amazing!! We are very picky from NY and most area restaurants are not up to our standards. This restaurant was so perfect and beautifully decorated for the holiday season. Our waitress Peggy was awesome! She was friendly and professional and knew the menu inside out. Food was incredible. I had beef tenderloin cooked perfectly to medium rare. Others had the lamb and the pork osso bucco and said it was fabulous. Drinks and desserts were also yummy. Great experience and will definitely return!","submittedDateTime":"2024-01-03T22:06:05Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":null,"isVip":null,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","initials":"OT","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":334,"endIndex":349,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"}],"photos":[{"photoMetaData":{"title":null,"photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/73034601.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"medium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/medium/1/73034601.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/73034601.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/1/73034601.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"DishPhoto"}],"__typename":"Dish"},{"dishId":"138553-352c05e84db29ca0dd8b2c0bba884906","name":"Chicken Milanese","description":"Served with Vegetables Risotto of the Day and a touch of Chimichurri","reviewCount":3,"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109781878-160040148076","text":"Food was very good. Chicken Milanese was excellent. Cheese and olive board was skimpy on olives compared to other tables. Wait time to get served our dinner was long. Overall, I recommend this charming restaurant.","submittedDateTime":"2024-03-19T20:30:27Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"BLWo","isVip":true,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","initials":"BL","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":20,"endIndex":36,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109778905-130043023933","text":"We liked the charm of the old house setting. The swordfish was fantastic although the chicken dish was not.","submittedDateTime":"2023-09-04T15:50:30Z","rating":{"overall":4,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"MarianneS","isVip":null,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","initials":"MS","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":87,"endIndex":94,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109773093-150042051565","text":"Amazing. Ordered the vegetable lasagna, chicken, and beef tenderloin dinners. All of us really enjoyed everything and the service was great. Can’t wait to come back.","submittedDateTime":"2022-07-10T20:17:12Z","rating":{"overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"nickname":"Lexi","isVip":true,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","initials":"L","simpleModerationState":"APPROVED","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"highlights":[{"startIndex":40,"endIndex":47,"__typename":"ReviewHighlight"}],"__typename":"DishReview"}],"photos":[{"photoMetaData":{"title":null,"photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/71294842.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"medium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/medium/1/71294842.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/71294842.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/1/71294842.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"__typename":"DishPhoto"}],"__typename":"Dish"}],"__typename":"PopularDishes"},"__typename":"Restaurant","diningAreas":[{"name":"Other","diningAreaId":1,"description":"Other","tag":"Other","localeMatch":true,"active":true,"preProcessedAreaId":null,"__typename":"DiningAreaMetaData"}],"privateDining":{"hasPrivateDining":false,"hasEnhancedPrivateDining":false,"description":null,"formattedPhone":null,"contact":"","largestCapacity":50,"__typename":"PrivateDining"},"seoTranslations":{"metaTitle":"%(restaurantName)s Restaurant - %(locationName)s | OpenTable","__typename":"SeoTranslations"},"restaurantReviewSummary":{"summary":"Old City House offers a charming dining experience with \"fantastic service\" and \"amazing food\" in a cozy, historic setting. Guests frequently laud the \"quaint ambiance\" and \"superb\" dishes like lamb and crab cakes. The patio and courtyard provide a \"romantic\" atmosphere, perfect for special occasions. Highly recommended for a memorable meal in St. Augustine.","__typename":"RestaurantReviewSummaryGenerativeContent"},"awards":[]},"menus":{"menuData":[{"title":"Dinner Menu","description":"Split Plate $10 Upcharge","currency":{"code":"USD","__typename":"MenuCurrency"},"sections":[{"title":"Appetizers","description":"","items":[{"title":"Escargot a la Bourguignonne","description":"","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Shrimp Cocktail","description":"","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cheese & Olives Board","description":"Chef Selection of Mixed Cheeses and Olives","price":"18.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Shrimp & Scallops Ceviche","description":"","price":"15.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Pan Seared Ahi Tuna","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Soups","description":"","items":[{"title":"She Crab Bisque","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Cup","price":"10.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bowl","price":"12.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Soup Of The Day","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Cup","price":"8.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bowl","price":"10.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Salads","description":"","items":[{"title":"House Salad","description":"Organic Baby Greens, Garnished with Fresh Cucumbers, Carrots and Tomatoes. Served with your choice of White Balsamic Vinaigrette, Sun Dried Tomato, Roasted Garlic, Passion Fruit Vinaigrette or Ranch Dressings","price":"7.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Red & Golden Beet Salad","description":"Organic Baby Greens, Tossed in Sun Dried Tomato Dressing. Served with Fried Panko Crusted Goat Cheese, topped with Red & Golden Beets and Crumbled Goat Cheese","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Main Courses","description":"","items":[{"title":"Vegetable Lasagna","description":"Cauliflower, Zucchini, Squash, Carrots, Onions, Sweet Peppers, Baby Spinach and Homemade Marinara","price":"30.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Chicken Milanese","description":"Served with Vegetables, Risotto of the Day, and a touch of Chimichurri","price":"32.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Pork Osso Bucco","description":"Braised Pork Shank served with Vegetables, Roasted Potatoes, and Homemade Demi-Glace Sauce","price":"37.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Fish of the Day","description":"Baked Salmon served with Vegetables, Fried Yuca and Homemade Sauce","price":"35.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cioppino","description":"Shrimp, Scallops, Clams, Mussels and Fish Sauteed in a Lemon, Cilantro and Tomato broth","price":"38.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Beef Tenderloin","description":"Served with Vegetables, Gratin Potatoes and Topped with Herb and Truffle Butter","price":"44.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Old City House Crab Cake","description":"Served with Vegetables, Mashed Potatoes, and Homemade Sriracha Aioli","price":"36.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Pan Seared Pork Chop","description":"Served with Vegetables, Roasted Potatoes, and Homemade Demi-Glace Sauce","price":"38.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Herb & Garlic Marinated New Zealand Rack of Lamb","description":"Served with Vegetables, Mashed Potatoes, and Homemade Sherry Port Reduction","price":"42.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Veal Meatloaf","description":"Served with Vegetables, Mashed Potatoes, Homemade Demi-Glace Sauce and Homemade Ketchup","price":"36.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Red Wines","description":"","items":[],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Pinot Noir","description":"","items":[{"title":"10 Span Pinot Noir, Central Coast","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Inscription Pinot Noir, Oregon","description":"","price":"13.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cline Pinot Noir, Sonoma","description":"","price":"43.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"King Estate Pinot Noir, Oregon","description":"","price":"55.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Twomey Pinot Noir, Russian River","description":"","price":"88.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Merlot","description":"","items":[{"title":"St. Francis Merlot, Sonoma","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"St. Supery Merlot, Rutherford","description":"","price":"74.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Plumpjack Merlot, Napa","description":"","price":"110.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Cabernet Sauvignon","description":"","items":[{"title":"Liberty School Cabernet Sauvignon, Paso Robles","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Louis Martini Cabernet Sauvignon, California","description":"","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Frog's Leap Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa","description":"","price":"89.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cade Cabernet Sauvignon, Howell Mountain","description":"","price":"165.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cakebread Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa","description":"","price":"140.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon, Alexander Valley","description":"","price":"135.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"ZD Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa","description":"","price":"89.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Round Pond \"Kith & Kin\" Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa","description":"","price":"65.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Interesting Reds","description":"","items":[{"title":"Bodegas Muriel Crianza, Spain","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"San Sebastian Vintners Red, St. Augustine","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cline Ancient Vines Zinfandel, Contra Costa","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Banfi Chianti Classico, Italy","description":"","price":"38.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Masi Costasera Amarone, Italy","description":"","price":"89.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Banfi Brunello di Montacino, Tuscany","description":"","price":"140.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Norton \"Privada\" Red Blend, Argentina","description":"","price":"15.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Trivento Golden Reserve Malbec, Argentina","description":"","price":"52.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Callia Malbec, Argentina","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Chateau Mezain Cabernet-Merlot, France","description":"","price":"42.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Sparkling Wines","description":"","items":[{"title":"Maschino Prosecco Brut, Italy","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Split","price":"8.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Jean-Louis Ice Blanc de Blanc, France","description":"","price":"35.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Santa Margherita Prosecco, Italy","description":"","price":"42.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Moncalvina Moscato, Italy","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Taittinger Brut La Francaise, France","description":"","price":"95.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Luc Belaire Brut Rose, France","description":"","price":"65.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Dom Perignon Brut, France","description":"","price":"290.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"White Wines","description":"","items":[],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Pinot Grigio | Pinot Gris","description":"","items":[{"title":"Caposaldo Pinot Grigio, Italy","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"A to Z Pinot Gris, Oregon","description":"","price":"11.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Santa Margherita Pinot Grigio, Italy","description":"","price":"40.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Sauvignon Blanc","description":"","items":[{"title":"St. Supery Sauvignon Blanc, Napa","description":"","price":"11.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Whiteheaven Sauvignon Blanc, New-Zealand","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Frog's Leap Sauvignon Blanc, Napa","description":"","price":"39.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Twoney Sauvignon Blanc, Napa","description":"","price":"44.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Chardonnay","description":"","items":[{"title":"Balletto Unoaked Chardonnay, Russian River","description":"","price":"11.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Clos Pegase Chardonnay, Napa","description":"","price":"48.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"BR Cohn Chardonnay, Sonoma","description":"","price":"13.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"ZD Chardonnay, California","description":"","price":"55.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cakebread Chardonnay, Napa","description":"","price":"78.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Alternative Whites & Rosé","description":"","items":[{"title":"Thomas Schmitt Riesling, Germany","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"San Sebastián Vintners White, St. Augustine","description":"","price":"10.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Cloud Chaser Rosé, Provence","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"}],"updated":"2022-08-10T03:24:14.64","provider":{"name":"OpenTable","image":{"altText":"","url":"","height":24,"__typename":"ProviderImage"},"__typename":"MenuProvider"},"__typename":"Menu"},{"title":"Lunch Menu","description":"","currency":{"code":"USD","__typename":"MenuCurrency"},"sections":[{"title":"Soup","description":"","items":[{"title":"She Crab Soup","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Cup","price":"7.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bowl","price":"9.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Soup of The Day","description":"","price":null,"variationGroups":[{"items":[{"title":"Cup","price":"6.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bowl","price":"8.00","__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuVariationGroup"}],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Salads","description":"","items":[{"title":"House Salad","description":"Choice of Dressing: Organic Baby Greens garnished with Cucumber and Tomato","price":"7.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Red & Golden Beet Salad","description":"Organic baby greens and tossed in sun-dried tomato dressing placed over panko crusted, fried goat cheese topped with beets and crumbled goat cheese","price":"9.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Traditional Chicken Salad","description":"Served with Fresh fruit, Organic Greens & Passion Fruit Vinaigrette","price":"15.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Lunch Drink Special","description":"","items":[{"title":"Mimosa","description":"Choice of orange juice or cranberry","price":"6.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Sangria","description":"Choice red or white","price":"6.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bloody Mary","description":"","price":"6.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Appetizers","description":"","items":[{"title":"Fried Cauliflower","description":"","price":"8.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Jumbo Lump Crab Meat Cocktail","description":"","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Pan Seared Ahi Tuna","description":"","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Grilled Fish Tacos","description":"Served With Rice Sour Cream, Slaw And Salsa, Cilantro Lime Aioli","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Vegetarian Empanadas","description":"Served With Pesto Chimichurri And Cilantro; Lime Cream","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Meat Ravioli","description":"With Chorizo Cream Sauce And Organic Sate Baby Spinach","price":"12.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"},{"title":"Sandwiches","description":"Sandwiches Served Choice Of 1 Side Fresh Fruit, Pineapple Slow, French Fries Or Vegetables Couscous Salad","items":[{"title":"Chicken Milanese Sandwich","description":"Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions","price":"12.50","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Bacon Beef Short Rib Cheese Burger","description":"Lettuce Tomato Onions","price":"16.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Veal Meatloaf Sandwich","description":"Lettuce Tomato, Onions And Home Made Ketchup","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Crab Cake Sandwich","description":"Lettuce, Tomato, Onions Avocado","price":"13.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"},{"title":"Vegetarian Grilled Portabella Pesto Sandwich","description":"With Grilled Zucchin, Squash And Red Bell Peppers","price":"14.00","variationGroups":[],"__typename":"MenuSectionItem"}],"__typename":"MenuSection"}],"updated":"2022-02-01T12:39:33.695","provider":{"name":"OpenTable","image":{"altText":"","url":"","height":24,"__typename":"ProviderImage"},"__typename":"MenuProvider"},"__typename":"Menu"}],"menuInfo":{"showThirdPartyMenu":true,"url":null,"__typename":"MenuInfo"}},"isHuman":false,"metaLinks":{"isIndexed":false,"hrefLangs":[{"href":"https://www.opentable.com/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-US","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com/old-city-house?lang=es","hrefLang":"es-US","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.jp/old-city-house","hrefLang":"ja-JP","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.de/old-city-house","hrefLang":"de-DE","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.es/old-city-house","hrefLang":"es-ES","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ca/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-CA","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ca/old-city-house?lang=fr","hrefLang":"fr-CA","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.hk/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-HK","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ie/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-IE","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.sg/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-SG","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.nl/old-city-house","hrefLang":"nl-NL","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com.mx/old-city-house","hrefLang":"es-MX","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.co.uk/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-GB","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com.au/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-AU","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.ae/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-AE","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.co.th/old-city-house","hrefLang":"en-TH","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.it/old-city-house","hrefLang":"it-IT","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.com.tw/old-city-house","hrefLang":"zh-TW","__typename":"HrefLang"},{"href":"https://www.opentable.fr/old-city-house","hrefLang":"fr-FR","__typename":"HrefLang"}],"canonical":"https://www.opentable.ae/old-city-house","__typename":"PageMetaData"},"reviewsData":{"reviewSearchResults":{"reviews":[{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787585-130079123293","text":"A wonderful Anniversary dinner. We hadn’t been for a while and it was as delicious as we remembered","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":3,"nickname":"Lynne","metro":{"metroId":9,"displayName":"Washington DC","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"L","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-16T10:28:06Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-13T18:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787463-110028952761","text":"Once again, this restaurant lived up to what we’ve always experienced which is great good, service and ambiance!","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"MODERATE","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":17,"nickname":"GARY","metro":{"metroId":26,"displayName":"Milwaukee","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"G","isVip":true,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-14T11:11:23Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-11T17:30:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109786437-170034550227","text":"We had such a great time during our anniversary visit. Staff is so nice, the food is excellent! The rooms are comfortable, they have everything you need. Would definitely recommend this for a romantic stay. It’s very close to everything as well, we walked everywhere.","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":4,"nickname":"Sara","metro":{"metroId":84,"displayName":"Tampa","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"S","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"PLUM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-14T16:16:16Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-11T17:30:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787530-110004221431","text":"Fine dining in the center of America’s Oldest City! Esteban was amazing. What else one could ask for.","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"DO_NOT_RECALL","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":3,"nickname":"Gene","metro":{"metroId":17,"displayName":"Miami","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"G","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"PLUM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-14T17:42:56Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-11T12:15:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787409-160023378566","text":"We had made a Mother’s Day reservation for noon because OpenTable showed that they had a lunch menu. When we sat down, we were told there was no lunch menu only dinner, which was significantly bigger meals at much higher prices than what was expected. Unfortunately, the person that wanted the lunch menu that was listed was the mother that we were celebrating… Everyone else liked the food but it kind of ruined the point of going there for Mother’s Day. They need to get their information correct online.","rating":{"food":4,"service":5,"ambience":3,"value":2,"noise":"DO_NOT_RECALL","overall":3,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":8,"nickname":"Lori","metro":{"metroId":89,"displayName":"Atlantic City","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"L","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"PUMPKIN","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-14T12:43:08Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-11T12:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787531-190124652109","text":"This place is Amazing! Great service, atmosphere, and the food is Delicious!\nWe went for our anniversary and at the end surprised us with an anniversary dessert.\nWhat a nice touch!","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"MODERATE","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":2,"nickname":"Lisa","metro":{"metroId":83,"displayName":"Jacksonville","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"L","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-13T14:50:05Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-10T18:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[{"photoId":"77635080","type":null,"photoMetaData":{"title":null,"source":"Diner","creator":"OpenTable","timestamp":"2025-05-13T14:50:16Z","photoBySize":{"small":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/small/1/77635080.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"medium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/medium/1/77635080.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"xlarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/xlarge/1/77635080.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideMedium":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-medium/1/77635080.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"wideLarge":{"url":"https://resizer.otstatic.com/v2/photos/wide-large/1/77635080.jpg","__typename":"Photo"},"__typename":"PhotoSizes"},"__typename":"PhotoMetadata"},"caption":"Anniversary Surprise!","showCaption":true,"__typename":"ReviewPhoto"}],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787506-140062698984","text":"Celebrated my wife's birthday here for a special dinner (and they made her feel special, too!). It was outstanding! Service was superb. We had a table for two in the dining room. Our server was knowledgeable and gave great advice. My wife had the fish of the day special and I had the rack of lamb. As an appetizer, we ordered the cheese and olive board. All were excellent. We will be back.","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":4,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":2,"nickname":"Patrick","metro":{"metroId":82,"displayName":"Tallahassee","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"P","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-12T12:05:47Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-09T18:30:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787199-170079004927","text":"This dining experience is a cross of fine dining and old world hospitality. Great menu, great service and charming setting. Very romantic.","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":9,"nickname":"Lee","metro":{"metroId":8,"displayName":"New York City","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"L","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"PLUM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-12T12:17:29Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-08T19:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787519-180031310748","text":"Quaint old building with lots of charm. Fantastic service with friendly staff. Our dinners were presented equal to a 5 star restaurant and tasted equally good! Only down size is portions were very small for the price. Still worth trying though!","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":3,"noise":"DO_NOT_RECALL","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":15,"nickname":"Jayne","metro":{"metroId":3483,"displayName":"West Palm Beach","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"J","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"MUSTARD","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-05-10T12:25:48Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-05-07T17:00:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"},{"reviewId":"OT-138553-2109787336-170158137697","text":"This was a pleasant find. Ambience was warm and inviting. Staff were great and very pleasant. We both had rack of lamb which was the best lamb over ever had ! \nWonderful evening","rating":{"food":5,"service":5,"ambience":5,"value":5,"noise":"QUIET","overall":5,"__typename":"ReviewRating"},"user":{"numOfApprovedReviews":2,"nickname":"Marta","metro":{"metroId":84,"displayName":"Tampa","__typename":"Metro"},"initials":"M","isVip":null,"isLoggedInUser":false,"profileColor":"ICECREAM","profilePhoto":{"photoBySize":null,"__typename":"PublicDinerProfilePhoto"},"__typename":"ReviewUser"},"helpfulness":{"up":0,"down":0,"score":0,"__typename":"ReviewHelpfulness"},"publicRestaurantReply":null,"submittedDateTime":"2025-04-29T16:39:31Z","dinedDateTime":"2025-04-26T18:15:00-04:00","type":"OPENTABLEVERIFIED","fromPreviousConcept":false,"highlight":null,"photos":[],"__typename":"ReviewSearchResult"}],"totalPages":225,"page":1,"totalCount":2242,"__typename":"ReviewSearchResults"},"reviewHelpfulnessVotes":[],"sortBy":"newestReview","isLoading":false,"prioritiseUserLanguage":false,"searchTerm":"","error":false},"availabilityToken":null,"noAvailabilityList":null,"multiDayAvailabilityModalOpen":false,"showDiningReward":false,"initialDTPDate":null,"initialDTPTime":null,"initialDTPPartySize":null,"fetchAvailabilityOnLoad":false,"findATableLoadingStateOverride":true,"pointRedemptionRewards":null,"privateDining":{},"activeTab":"overview","disableFPC":true,"restaurantHighlights":{"staff":null,"missionStatement":null},"pageAnchor":null},"wallet":{"isPaymentLoading":false,"singleUseCard":null,"savedCards":[],"selectedPaymentCardId":null,"showAddPaymentsMethodModal":false,"showConfirmDeleteModal":false,"cardIdForDeletion":null,"paymentCardTokenToSaveAfterLogin":null,"errorCode":null,"showPaymentMethodSavedToast":null,"showPaymentMethodRemovedToast":null,"networkError":null,"partialErrors":[]}},"__OT_NEW_SESSION_START__":true,"__EXCLUDE_ONETRUST__":false,"__EXCLUDE_GA__":false,"__INCLUDE_RECAPTCHA__":false,"__OT_RUM_CONTEXT__":{"deviceType":"desktop","primaryCountry":"ae"},"__OT_GA_DATA__":{"cd2":72,"cd12":"en","cd6":138553,"cd28":138553,"cd13":"Full Web","cd17":"Full Web","cd11":"restprofilepage","cd66":"restaurants","cd63":"restaurant-profile","cd67":"network","cd10":"anonymous","cd7":"Logged Out","cd4":290,"cd76":290,"cd3":83,"cd19":83,"cd78":869,"cd5":869,"cd31":"false","cd85":1,"cd84":"GuestCenter","cd15":"network","cd18":"network"}}}
features creative cuisine, spiced with variety, in a casually elegant dining atmosphere. Located in a beautifully restored 19th century building, the Old City House offers it’s guests the chance to experience a personal selection of world cuisine in a Mediterranean atmosphere. Only the finest ingredients are used and all entrees are prepared to order featuring fresh seafood, pasta, beef, lamb, and pork. The intimate and charming dining room is conducive to a relaxed, comfortable meal which is served by a knowledgeable and professional wait staff.
Additional information
Dining style
Casual Dining
Price
$31 to $50
Cuisines
Contemporary American
Hours of operation
Dinner
Mon–Thu 5:00 pm–9:00 pm
Fri, Sat 4:30 pm–10:00 pm
Sun 4:30 pm–8:00 pm
Public parking by the lightner museum free daily after 5:00 pm
Public transit
Flagler College, front of Lightner Museum home of Alcazar Hotelnext to Casa Monica Hotel Side of St. George st. two minutes from Lincolnville
Additional
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Corkage Fee, Full Bar, Non-Smoking, Outdoor Smoking Area, Private Room, Wine
Popular dishes
Menu
Old City House's menu was last updated on 8/10/2022.
Split Plate $10 Upcharge
Appetizers
Escargot a la Bourguignonne$14.00
Shrimp Cocktail$14.00
Cheese & Olives Board$18.00
Chef Selection of Mixed Cheeses and Olives
Shrimp & Scallops Ceviche$15.00
Pan Seared Ahi Tuna$12.00
Soups
She Crab Bisque
Cup$10.00
Bowl$12.00
Soup Of The Day
Cup$8.00
Bowl$10.00
Salads
House Salad$7.00
Organic Baby Greens, Garnished with Fresh Cucumbers, Carrots and Tomatoes. Served with your choice of White Balsamic Vinaigrette, Sun Dried Tomato, Roasted Garlic, Passion Fruit Vinaigrette or Ranch Dressings
Red & Golden Beet Salad$12.00
Organic Baby Greens, Tossed in Sun Dried Tomato Dressing. Served with Fried Panko Crusted Goat Cheese, topped with Red & Golden Beets and Crumbled Goat Cheese
Old City House reviews from people who’ve dined at this restaurant. Based on recent rating.
Overall ratings and reviews
Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant
4.8
4.8 based on recent ratings
4.8Food
4.8Service
4.8Ambience
4.6Value
Noise • Moderate
Loved For
Jacksonville / Northeast Florida
Romantic
Jacksonville / Northeast Florida
Contemporary American
St. Augustine
Best Overall
St. Augustine
Best Food
St. Augustine
Best Service
St. Augustine
Best Ambiance
St. Augustine
Best Value
St. Augustine
Neighborhood gem
St. Augustine
Great for fine wines
St. Augustine
Great for outdoor dining
St. Augustine
Romantic
St. Augustine
Good for special occasions
Review summary
AI-generated from verified diner reviews
Old City House offers a charming dining experience with "fantastic service" and "amazing food" in a cozy, historic setting. Guests frequently laud the "quaint ambiance" and "superb" dishes like lamb and crab cakes. The patio and courtyard provide a "romantic" atmosphere, perfect for special occasions. Highly recommended for a memorable meal in St. Augustine.
2,242 Reviews
L
Lynne
Washington DC3 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
A wonderful Anniversary dinner. We hadn’t been for a while and it was as delicious as we remembered
Is this helpful?
G
GARY VIP
Milwaukee17 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Once again, this restaurant lived up to what we’ve always experienced which is great good, service and ambiance!
Is this helpful?
S
Sara
Tampa4 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
We had such a great time during our anniversary visit. Staff is so nice, the food is excellent! The rooms are comfortable, they have everything you need. Would definitely recommend this for a romantic stay. It’s very close to everything as well, we walked everywhere.
Is this helpful?
G
Gene
Miami3 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Fine dining in the center of America’s Oldest City! Esteban was amazing. What else one could ask for.
Is this helpful?
L
Lori
Atlantic City8 reviews
3.0
Dined 6 days ago
Overall 3
Food 4
Service 5
Ambience 3
We had made a Mother’s Day reservation for noon because OpenTable showed that they had a lunch menu. When we sat down, we were told there was no lunch menu only dinner, which was significantly bigger meals at much higher prices than what was expected. Unfortunately, the person that wanted the lunch menu that was listed was the mother that we were celebrating… Everyone else liked the food but it kind of ruined the point of going there for Mother’s Day. They need to get their information correct online.
Is this helpful?
L
Lisa
Jacksonville2 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
This place is Amazing! Great service, atmosphere, and the food is Delicious!
We went for our anniversary and at the end surprised us with an anniversary dessert.
What a nice touch!
Is this helpful?
P
Patrick
Tallahassee2 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 9, 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 4
Celebrated my wife's birthday here for a special dinner (and they made her feel special, too!). It was outstanding! Service was superb. We had a table for two in the dining room. Our server was knowledgeable and gave great advice. My wife had the fish of the day special and I had the rack of lamb. As an appetizer, we ordered the cheese and olive board. All were excellent. We will be back.
Is this helpful?
L
Lee
New York City9 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 8, 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
This dining experience is a cross of fine dining and old world hospitality. Great menu, great service and charming setting. Very romantic.
Is this helpful?
J
Jayne
West Palm Beach15 reviews
5.0
Dined on May 7, 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
Quaint old building with lots of charm. Fantastic service with friendly staff. Our dinners were presented equal to a 5 star restaurant and tasted equally good! Only down size is portions were very small for the price. Still worth trying though!
Is this helpful?
M
Marta
Tampa2 reviews
5.0
Dined on April 26, 2025
Overall 5
Food 5
Service 5
Ambience 5
This was a pleasant find. Ambience was warm and inviting. Staff were great and very pleasant. We both had rack of lamb which was the best lamb over ever had !
Wonderful evening
Is this helpful?
FAQs
Old City House is rated 4.8 stars by 2242 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable.