Best Historic Restaurants in Coney Island

Fantastic late night dinner at Essex Bar! Yellowtail Crudo was beautiful and a refreshing start to a wonderful meal, and Duck Pasta was perfectly prepared. Desserts, especially the flourless chocolate cake were standouts. Wife had the bone-in strip steak, which was huge and flavorful. Nice selection value wines. Will be back.

Our dining experience at this charming restaurant was nothing short of delightful. The rich history of the establishment added a unique and inviting atmosphere, complemented by its cozy ambiance. The drink menu was exceptional, featuring standout options like the Paper Plane, which is a personal favorite and is listed as one of their signature cocktails. The Spicy Margarita was equally impressive, offering a perfect balance of heat and flavor. To start, the pear salad was a refreshing and flavorful choice, setting the tone for the meal. However, the true highlight of the evening was the pot pie. The crust was impeccably flaky and golden, while the filling was rich, savory, and utterly satisfying. The service was both friendly and efficient, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable dining experience from start to finish. This restaurant is a gem, and we highly recommend it for anyone seeking a memorable meal in a warm and historic setting.

The Israeli host was absolutely incredible and made sure we had a good service and experience. I am very pleased. The service was great and the food was amazing, the concept of the outdoor seating is so nice, we had an amazing time

Gargiulo's is a Coney Island institution. The food is excellent, as is the service. With Chef Matthew Cutolo, we're never disappointed. Classic Italian cuisine, with a modern twist. Do yourself a favor, take a walk on the Boardwalk, and end up at Gargiulo's. You'll not be disappointed.

This was our first visit to Temple Court, and we can’t wait to go back. For a Restaurant Week lunch, the choices were excellent, the portions more than adequate, and EVERYTHING was delicious.