Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Montauk

I'm so grateful for the experience. My son is training at the Naval Base in Newport, and he was able to have Thanksgiving off. I was able to get reservations within a week of the holiday. The staff was exceptional, and the food was amazing. I will definitely be coming back.

Great service. Came here for Thanksgiving - the Thanksgiving special menu was amazing. The deviled eggs with caviar were a surprising delight. The Thanksgiving plate was truly amazing and surely beat doing the cooking myself. Our table also ordered seafood which was done perfectly. The mixed drinks were perfectly blended. Our server was cheerful and prompt - highly recommend

This was our first time there, food was great and service was impeccable, we will be back next time we are in town.

As always, the Coast Guard House lived up to its excellent reputation for outstanding food, service, and friendliness. The menu options and wine choices are also excellent. Very highly recommended. It also happens to be a very historic building that was repurposed very appropriately into the excellent restaurant that it is and continues to be.

Always great..... Food and Staff always top notch...