Best American Restaurants in Bay Village

My husband and I come here every year for Valentine's Day. Although it was very busy, it wasn't that loud. My scooby snack was amazing as always. My mimosa was pretty strong. Tasted like it was straight up champagne. The waiter was great and nice.

Valentines Pre-Fixed was absolutely outstanding. The Lobster Cavatelli is worth the price of admission alone. Our Server Jessica was outstanding - attentive, thoughtful, and considerate. My NY Strip was slightly undercooked from my Medium request, but the kitchen was undoubtedly earning their keep on a busy night. Would definitely return, and this is a great spot to celebrate Valentine’s.

Grill 23 on Valentine's Day was as spectacular as usual. We started out with the Seafood Tower, had a French Onion Soup, followed it with a Wedge Salad, and then the Rib Eye. Food was awesome as ever and the bread basket was filled with great goodies such as corn bread, raisin pumpernickel, and more. The extensive wine list provided a lot of choices and we started with a Paul Hobbs and ended with a Screaming Eagle.

Clayton was great. Have come multiple times and will continue to come back. Carl? (Chef) does a great job - food is always well-crafted, flavorful and creative. Staff is kind, professional and genuine. Good spacing on tables, great cocktails/wine pairings. Definitely the spot to go to!

The experience was delightful starting with the drinks very well made concoctions and the appetizers to the meals then deserts do not disappoint. Service was great and extremely professional displayed for a great Valentines dinner with my wife. Definitely worth it and the food made from scratch suits all for accommodations. The scenery with the dimmed lights and portraits throughout made for a nice setting to dine in.