Best Italian Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Absolutely amazing experience at lunch. Can't wait to come back for dinner!

Tony's is a family style Italian restaurant right in Time's Square and in the heart of the theater district. There is a parking garage right next door with entrances both on 43rd and 44th. Tony's will even validate the parking stub! Everything at Tony's is delicious but bring a big appetite as the servings are very large! We have been coming to Tony's for years... highly recommend!!

From the time I walked into the restaurant, (about 15 minutes late), hostess didn’t give me an issue about being late, was very professional, and seated my group within 3 minutes. From the moment we were seated, I was BLOWN away, by the service. Everyone was extremely nice, service was TOP TIER! Our server Chris D. was hands down the BEST! Now let’s get to the food, there was only the 2 of of us, and when our food arrived, we were overwhelmed just by looking at the portions. Food was amazing, drinks were excellent. I will definitely be back!

We went for restaurant week dinner. This is the only restaurant that I've been to that includes 2 glasses of wine in the deal. There was a class of prosecco to start and a dessert wine at the end. They also had a deal that was $23 for 2 additional glasses of wine. The cesare salad was delicious and the antipasto had an extensive assortment of vegetables and seafood. For main course, we had one chicken Parmigiana and the pork chops. The portions were enormous! There were two huge chops which were tender and tasty. We took half of both entrees home! The cheesecake was incredible. I'd go back just for it, lol. All in all, we had an incredible experience at Becco.

This was my second time at Bad Roman and the food was delicious all around and the staff was super friendly! Thank you for being a well-rounded and reasonable place to come to in the neighborhood. We’ll be back!