Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Oyster Bay

Food and service was outstanding and they offered some high end upgrades with caviar and truffle options. What a gem in oyster bay

Went there for dinner with friends for birthday celebration. We have been there many times but this time we were disappointed in several dishes and told manager who didn’t do anything. Later Juliet came over and took care of the situation. She listened to our complaint and handled the situation appropriately. She was professional and did the right thing to make us feel better about wanting to come back.

Our waiter, Michael , was very helpful in guiding us to our cocktail choices and explaining the menu. The tuna tartare was very fresh and abundant. The kettle chips were crispy and a great compliment to the tuna. The halibut was perfectly cooked, and tasted delightful with the mushrooms, shrimp, fingerling potatoes dressed in a lobster sauce. The pumpkin cocktail evoked the spirit of autumn. The bread pudding was elevated with blueberries and vanilla bean ice cream. All but the cocktail was part of the prix fixe menu. Fine dining at a fine price

We go every year for our anniversary since we got married at Fox Hollow 7 years ago. Food is always amazing! Service was great, we’ll be back again.

Love this place! Wines are organic so no headache. They do need a piece of fish on the menu and another salad choice.