Best Cozy Restaurants in Governors Island

I hesitate to EVER book a Valentine’s dinner in Manhattan….but WOW this was my best Valentine’s experience ever. It was a 3 course price fixe dinner with multiple options and all of them were “home runs” in the opinion of our party of five. Portions ample and the tastes were outstanding. Stellar experience.

We came to this place under the premise that the food was outstanding based on the Michelin rating and social media touting that the food was comparably to that in Thailand…..this was the reason we booked. The service was lovely, everyone friendly and attentive which is always appreciated. The shrimp pancake appetizer was an interactive delicious experience. The rose quartz drink I had done virgin and enjoyed. The shrimp pad Thai was delicious, noodles done well, very tasty. The Wagyu pho was recommended and underwhelming honestly. We enjoyed both of the desserts we ordered, the crème brûlée and mango ice cream served with sticky rice….this was a highlight for us. Would I say Value….Probably Not.

The Cafe Cluny is a West Village treasure still worthy of its reputation. It's a cozy establishment that specializes in French cuisine and you better make a reservation in advance; it's always packed. I love the French Onion soup, the burgers and frites--also the seafood is always fresh and well prepared. I live in the neighborhood and it is one of my good-to places. Bravo.

Very good soca with botarga. Excellent Echine de Porc! Will come back just for that dish. Salad was very fresh but the vinaigrette was a bit too vinegar forward. Dessert was a rice pudding with persimmon. Totally bland and not worth eating. Had a lovely glass of Côte de Rhône.

AMAZING STAFF!!! Very friendly and went out of way to be hospitable. Will be back for sure!