Best Romantic Restaurants in Fisher Island

Very special place for a special night out. The mansion is gorgeous, with beautiful details everywhere. The pool room is amazing! Service was perfect and food was delicious. The appetizer of fried calamari, zucchini and shrimp was large and delicious. The scallop entree was wonderful. Perfect place for a celebration!

Incredible Service at Nikki Beach! We had an amazing experience at Nikki Beach, and a huge part of that was thanks to Gabriel! From the moment we sat down, he was attentive, sociable, and genuinely kind. His great sense of humor and friendly personality made our visit even more enjoyable. He went above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed, and his positive energy was truly contagious. Gabriel is the kind of server who makes a lasting impression, and we can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend asking for him if you visit—he’s the best!

AMAZING! Marco our waiter was awesome and their truffle Cacio E Pepe was to die for! The atmosphere was great, and we were sat next to a lovely couple who we got to chat about the menu with. Definitely will be back (hopefully soon!!).

The food and drinks were truly incredible, and the energy in the restaurant was amazing. We sat outside and there were dancers throughout the night which was a really cool entertainment experience. My one annoyance was the overall service level. I don’t know if they were understaffed, or over busy, but it was just very slow. Definitely don’t want to be rushed - but we waited a longggg time to do anything, and then had a drink not show up until we asked for it 3 times. So, that was a small damper. Overall, this place was amazing. Definitely recommend it and would love to come back.

We had such a wonderful experience at catch, specially due to Luis (our waiter). He always made us feel at home and treated us warmly and extremely politely. Thanks Luis!